Loading...
Minutes - 2025 - Design Review Board - 02/13/2025 - RegularDESIGN REVIEW BOARD MINUTES The Design Review Board met in regular session on February 13, 2025. Lindgren presiding. 1. CALL TO ORDER: Meeting called to order at 6:17 p.m. 2. ROLL CALL: LINDGREN, MIHAN, MURPHY, NORTON, GRUBB, SAYER, GREER. Present: Norton, Greer, Murphy, Sayer, and Lindgren. Absent: Grubb and Mihan. A quorum is present. 3. CONSENT AGENDA: ALL CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS ARE CONSIDERED ACTION ITEMS. Consent Agenda items are considered to be routine and are acted on with one motion. There will be no separate discussion on these items unless a Design Review Board member or City Staff requests an item to be removed from the Consent Agenda for discussion. Items removed from the Consent Agenda will be placed on the Regular Agenda in a sequence determined by the Rules of Order. Any item on the Consent Agenda that contains written recommendations from the City of Eagle shall be adopted as part of the Design Review's Consent Agenda approval motion unless specifically stated otherwise. A. Minutes of January 23, 2025. (HC) B. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for the Approval of DR-2016-69-MOD1 - Building Addition to the Eagle Sewer District Blower Building - Eagle Sewer District: Eagle Sewer District, represented by Walter Lindgren with Lindgren Labrie Architecture, PLLC, is requesting design review approval of a 2,875-square foot building addition to the blower building for the Eagle Sewer District. The 33.94-acre site is located on the southeast comer of South Urban Gate Avenue and State Highway 44 at 100 South Urban Gate Avenue. (BAW) Sayer moves to approve the Consent Agenda. Seconded by Norton. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES. 4. UNFINISHED BUSINESS: None. 5. NEW BUSINESS: A. ACTION ITEM. DR-2024-29 - 269 East Idaho Mixed Use Building - Michelle Webb: Michelle Webb, represented by Julie Benintendi with BRS Architects, is requesting design review approval for a 6,910-square foot, three-story, mixed use building (four residential units and two office [business and professional]/retail) units). The 0.16-acre site is located on the south side of East Idaho Street approximately 78-feet west of the intersection of East Idaho Street and North 2nd Street at 269 East Idaho Street. (ERF) Lindgren recuses himself from items 5A and 5B due to a conflict of interest. Vice Chairman Greer introduces the item. Mark Anderson, BRS Architects, 1010 South Allante Place, Suite 100, Boise, Idaho, 83709 provides an overview of the application, reviews staffs conditions and responds to questions from the Board. City Planner, Emily Falco, provides an overview of the application and responds to questions from the Commission. The board believes that the design does not comply with city code, the downtown design standards and has concerns with parking. Overall, there is a lot going on for such a small space. Additionally, the plans are not stamped by a licensed architect. They would like to applicant to consider the discussion that occurred tonight and come back with an updated stamped plan. Greer makes a motion to continue action item 5A - DR-2024-29 - 269 East Idaho Mixed Use Building with the same conditions as imposed by staff and hopefully some of the discussion has been helpful it seems that this area probably requires definitely an exterior reconsideration for the design. We don't want to dictate design, but we do have to make sure that it complies so that we are protecting the interest of the City. Seconded by Murphy. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES. B. ACTION ITEM. DR-2024-30 - 269 East Idaho Street Mixed Use Building Master Sign Plan Michelle Webb: Michelle Webb, represented by Julie Benintendi with BRS Architects, is requesting design review approval for a master sign plan for a mixed use building (four residential units and two office [business and professional]/retail) units). The 0.16-acre site is located on the south side of East Idaho Street approximately 78-feet west of the intersection of East Idaho Street and North 2nd Street at 269 East Idaho Street. (ERF) Greer moves to continue item DR-2024-30 - 269 East Idaho Street Mixed Use Building for the Master Sign Plan. Seconded by Sayer. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES. C. ACTION ITEM. DR-2024-78 - Emergency Services Building for Eagle Fire Station No. 4 within Lakemoor Subdivision - Method PMAP: Eagle Fire Department, represented by Jo D. Greer with Method PMAP, is requesting design review approval of 13,560-square foot, two story, emergency services building for Eagle Fire Station No. 4. The 0.89-acre site is located on the northwest corner of South Three Bridges Way and East Colchester Drive at 2489 South Three Bridges Way (Lot 2, Block 8, Lakemoor Subdivision No. 3). (BAW) Lindgren continues the meeting as Chairman and introduces the item. Vice Chairman Greer recuses herself from the item as she is the representative. Tyler Lewis, 119 East State Street, Eagle, Idaho, Fire Chief for the Eagle Protection Fire District, introduces himself and is excited about this project and will be available for operational questions. Jo Greer, 4240 West Lovegood Lane, Meridian, Idaho, 83646, provides an overview of the application and responds to questions from the Board. Chief Tyler Lewis responds to questions from the Board regarding trash service and the parking bays. Josh Reincur, 5303 West Fairmont Street, landscape architect, responds to questions from the Board. City Planner, Barb Willims, provides an overview of the application and responds to questions from the Commission. Lindgren makes a recommendation for approval of action item 5C - DR-2024-78 with the stated site specific conditions that have been provided 1 through 11 as stated and with the addition of site specific condition number 12 which is that the signage that is located, the number 4 that is shown around the building as well as the lettering Eagle Fire Station Number 4 and what have you is provided for reference only on this application that the applicant intends to submit a separate sign application at a later date that would be reviewed by this Board. That is site specific number 12. Site specific condition number 13 is where conflicts occur between floor plans and elevations meaning store front window locations that the exterior elevations will supersede and that the applicant has stated that those are full windows without in applique but that they are full windows and so that the intent is essentially there will be space behind it and we understand that there will be potentially perpendicular walls that will intersect with that and that will be coordinated and if we can have that be reviewed by staff and one member of the Board will be fine on that one. That was site specific condition number 13. Site specific number 14 that the applicant will provide some additional information regarding the 3m film that was discussed to be applied to the upper clear story of the stair tower and glazed conditions and to get a better understanding of what that finish is going to look at best we can to be reviewed by staff and one member of the Board. Seconded by Sayer. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES. C.1. ACTION ITEM: Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for DR-2024-78 - Emergency Services Building for Eagle Fire Station No. 4 within Lakemoor Subdivision - Method PMAP: Eagle Fire Department, represented by Jo D. Greer with Method PMAP, is requesting design review approval of 13,560-square foot, two story, emergency services building for Eagle Fire Station No. 4. The 0.89- acre site is located on the northwest corner of South Three Bridges Way and East Colchester Drive at 2489 South Three Bridges Way (Lot 2, Block 8, Lakemoor Subdivision No. 3). (BAW) Lindgren makes a motion to recommend for approval action item C.1 Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for DR-2024-78 as presented with the approved motion under the previous application 5C. Seconded by Sayer. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES. Greer takes her seat back at the dais. 6. REPORTS: A. Design Review Board: A few members attended the municipal meeting training and states that it was very enlightening. B. Staff: City Planner, Barb Williams provides an update of pending applications for the next Design Review Board. 7. ADJOURNMENT: Sayer makes a motion for adjournment. Seconded by Greer. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES. Hearing no further business, the Board meeting adjourned. PECTFULLY SUBMITTED: .•••tosomeasosatt OF EAC •y '.•��Glla0ORgT�••.: : • •ySEA HOL CS , idCMCT �'•.,�sTq.. ;oF''0�;.•'� CLERK OF THE MEETING APPROVED: WALTER LINDGREN, CHAIRMAN 2/14/2025 MULTI -TENANT MIXED USE OFFICE (BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL)/RETAIL/RESIDENTIAL BUILDING DR-2.024-29 Eagle Design Review Board Meeting February 13, 2025 City Staff: Phone: E-Mail: Emily R. Falco, Planner II 208-939-0227 1 2 2/14/2025 3 Landscape Plan Urban Concrotn w;Brica Stronlccapo Section rlY Urban Concrete w!Brick Streetscapa Plan Vox Urban Concrete wiBrick Streetscape Section R 4 2 2/14/2025 Floor Plans 2 ftt%!1 fRAli 1 M JLEVEL Ilf lAk 3 GOWiliDPARCM 000f 5 6 3 2/14/2025 Building Elevations 7 8 4 2/14/2025 Finishes/Glazing 1 ,i19.1,...11,,1 MLIN 2 ,,,t,“11.7,01. lieSPES 9 10 5 2/14/2025 • Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors — Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use—SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley — SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) — SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line — SSC No. 11 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Building elevations — SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 11 Issues of Special Concern • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley — SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) — SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line — SSC No. 11 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Building elevations — SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 12 6 2/14/2025 Building Design, Materials, and Colors 6.17 3 tlhk Towne Planning Alen ,27 Ueuguunow bNId,n rtoriV114ne theiakwc ofdotimown aillu rarer, puamt enhmtco. and;poclal rmi Cont, dal rntphaxin• the <Iia000r.,fthe I tIu Toxnr. 1' lhootywooe Je.i n Irautns II OM 1on.Potmk butl,1111P 6IKh as the l: ogle & Itk ao i the tecle Ilow•1. Into flw design aid reitooloomewi of the oldr Tunve ,Inca meludtng. +eµ:,uJ Ire n,ownl u tAawaf mnl rl.•nw•nI )+:.:n ul p, pot n opens uP lw..rtlt., to twin' de.ten, twlule maintaining pWusiwefuss. sepoo.iwd hottmnul aniodmioii mid nlalen•tl ohattcen. ripanne i.tt k tsw Figure 0._4. ono 0.1*a hi@h conrntteal Irma land 13 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors - Deferred • Cross section of roof - SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry - Deferred • Lot coverage - Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street - SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location - 55C No. 4 • Historic light - SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing - SSC No. 6 • Tree removal - 55C No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use - Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use - SSC No. 8 • Terminal Island between parking spaces and alley -SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) - SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line - SSC No. 11 • Lighting - SSC No. 12 • Parking space length - Deferred • Parking spaces required - SSC No. 13 • Building elevations - SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans - SSC No. 15 14 7 2/14/2025 SSC No. 1 1. Provide a revised site plan noting that all above ground utilities are to be located underground. and no poles are permitted on the site. The revised site plan shall be reviewed and approved by staff prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. 15 ssues of Special C • Building design, materials, and colors — Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley — SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) — SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line — SSC No. 11 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Building elevations — SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 16 8 2/14/2025 SSC No. 2 2. Provide a roof cross section showing all rooftop mechanical units screened from view at eye level by the parapet walls. The cross section shall be reviewed and approved by staff prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. 17 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors — Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No. B • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley— SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) —SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line — SSC No. 11 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Building elevations — SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 18 9 2/14/2025 h. Building Entries: Building entries facing a street shall be recessed a nuninnuu of four feet 14'). Exceptions may be permitted if another building entry design feature can meet the intent of this requirement and is approved by the desi,u review board and city council. 19 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors - Deferred • Above ground utilities - SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof - SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry - Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street-SSC No, 3 • Bicycle rack location - SSC No. 4 • Historic light - SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing -SSC No. 6 • Tree removal - SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use - Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use - SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley -SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) - SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line - SSC No. 11 • Lighting-SSC No. 12 • Parking space length - Deferred • Parking spaces required - SSC No. 13 • Building elevations -SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans - SSC No. 15 20 10 2/14/2025 Lot Coverage Lot coverage by the footprint of the structure shall be a iniuituum of forty percent (4O°b) and a maximum of ninety live percent (95%) in which case off site parking shall be provided for. The lot coverage requirement may be waived if development of the lot as a parking lot is reviewed by the design review board and is approved by the council. Furthermore. the minimum lot coverage requirement may be reduced by the council for the purpose of providing adequate on site parking in accordance with the provisions of this title for structures that include residential uses on floors other than the ground floor. Lot coverage of ground floor — 29.4% Carport coverage — 6% Required lot coverage 40-95% lit'�i 51�1 IINI 21 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors - Deferred • Above ground utilities - SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof - SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry - Deferred • Lot coverage - Deferred • Bicycle rack location - SSC No. 4 • Historic light - SSC No, 5 • Metal roofing - SSC No. 6 • Tree removal - SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use - Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use - SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley -SSC No.9 • Terminal island (north end) - SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line - SSC No. 11 • Lighting - SSC No. 12 • Parking space length - Deferred • Parking spaces required - SSC No. 13 • Building elevations - SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans - SSC No. 15 22 11 2/14/2025 SSC No. 3 3. Provide a revised landscape plan showing the streetscape along East Idaho Street to match the Urban Concrete with brick Streetscape Plan as specified in the Downtown Grid Improvement Plan. The revised landscape plan shall be reviewed and approved by staff and one member of the Design Review Board prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. Urban Concrete wBBrick Sireeiscaoe Suction '6_,_ b., Urban Concrete w/Bnck Streetscape Plan View Urban Concrete w/Brick Streetscape Section 23 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors - Deferred • Above ground utilities - SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof - SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry - Deferred • Lot coverage - Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street - SSC No. 3 • Historic light - SSC No, 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal - SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use - Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use - SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley-SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) -SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line - SSC No. 11 • Lighting - SSC No. 12 • Parking space length - Deferred • Parking spaces required -SSC No. 13 • Building elevations -SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans - SSC No. 15 24 12 2/14/2025 IISSC No. 4 4. Provide a revised landscape furnishing zone. Tli a landscape plan showing the bicycle rack located on site and not within the sidewalk furnishing The revised landscape plan shall be reviewed and approved by staff prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. 25 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors — Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Metal roofing — 55C No. 5 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley — SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) — SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line — SSC No. 11 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Building elevations — SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 26 13 2/14/2025 SSC No. 5 Idaho 5. Provide detailed cutsheets for the historic light along EastnariItem Road. The detailed cutsheets shall be reviewed and approved by staff prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. 27 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors - Deferred • Above ground utilities - SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof - SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry - Deferred • Lot coverage - Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street - SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location - SSC No. 4 • Historic light - SSC No. 5 • Tree removal - SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use - Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use - SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley-SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) - SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line - SSC No. 11 • Lighting - SSC No. 12 • Parking space length - Deferred • Parking spaces required - SSC No. 13 • Building elevations - SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans - SSC No. 15 28 14 2/14/2025 SSC No. 6 6. Provide revised building elevations showing the metal roofing to have concealed fasteners. The revised elevations shall be reviewed and approved by staff prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. LIM 6COL ORa0.Y9 5. •11 • 29 110 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors — Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing —SSC No. 6 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley — SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) — SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line — SSC No. 11 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Building elevations — SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 30 15 2/14/2025 SSC No. 7 7. If the City approves the removal of the Silver Maple tree and does not require mitigation. the applicant nav opt to remove some or all the 39-caliper inches of trees shown on the landscape plan. -OR- If the City approves the removal of the Silver Maple tree. requires mitigation. and approves the proposed mitigation. no additional trees are required on the she. -OR- If the City approves the removal of the Silver Maple tree. it requires mitigation. and does not approve oldie proposed mitigation. the applicant shall be required to provide a revised landscape plan showing the additional 39-caliper inches of tree mitigated through an alternative way. The revised landscape plats shall be reviewed and approved by staff prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. -OR- If the City approves the removal of the Silver, Maple tree. it requires mitigation. and does not approve of the proposed mitigation. the applicant may opt to pay an in lies fee into the tree fund in the amount of SG.S25.00 139-caliper inches x S175.00 per caliper inch). The payment to the tree fund shall he received by the City prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. -OR- Any other combination of planting additional trees on site and/or a contribution to the tree fund as may be approved by the City. A revised landscape plan and'or contribution to the tree find should he reviewed and approved and/or submitted to the City prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. 31 Issues of Special Concern Building design, materials, and colors - Deferred Above ground utilities - SSC No. 1 Cross section of roof - SSC No. 2 Recessed entry - Deferred Lot coverage - Deferred Streetscape along East Idaho Street-SSC No. 3 Bicycle rack location - SSC No. 4 Historic light - SSC No. 5 Metal roofing - SSC No. 6 Tree removal - SSC No. 7 Buffer between parking lot and residential use - SSC No. 8 Terminal island between parking spaces and alley - SSC No. 9 Terminal island (north end{ - SSC No. 10 Buffer between parking lot and east property line - SSC No. 11 Lighting - 55C No. 12 Parking space length - Deferred Parking spaces required - SSC No. 13 Building elevations - SSC No. 14 Stamped plans - SSC No. 15 11111111117- 32 16 2/14/2025 Buffer between building and residential use ECC requires a 10' wide by 6' high buffer between the building and property line of a residential use. DDA Overlay district permits a 0' setback Applicant proposed a 5' wide buffer area between the building and west property line (has an existing fence). Half of the buffer area is landscaped and the other half is where the garbage and recycle totes are proposed to be stored. 33 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors - Deferred • Above ground utilities - SSC No. 1 Cross section of roof - SSC No. 2 Recessed entry- Deferred Lot coverage - Deferred Streetscape along East Idaho Street - SSC No. 3 Bicycle rack location - SSC No. 4 Historic light - SSC No, 5 Metal roofing - SSC No. 6 Tree removal - SSC No. 7 Buffer between building and residential use - Deferred Terminal island between parking spaces and alley - SSC No. 9 Terminal island (north end) - SSC No. 10 Buffer between parking lot and east property line - SSC No. 11 Lighting - SSC No. 12 Parking space length - Deferred Parking spaces required - SSC No. 13 Building elevations - SSC No. 14 Stamped plans - SSC No. 15 34 17 2/14/2025 SSC No. 8 8. Provide a revised landscape plan showing the landscape buffer between the west property line and parking lot planned with a minimum of 60-percent evergreen plant material. The revised landscape plan shall be reviewed and approved by staff and one Member of the Design Review Board prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. ECC requires a 5' wide by 6' high buffer between the parking lot and property line of a residential use planted with a minimum of 60% evergreen plant material. Applicant proposed a 5' wide buffer area between the parking area and west property line (has an existing fence) planted with Sunjoy Gold Pillar Barberry, Feather Reed Grass, and deciduous trees. 35 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors - Deferred -, • Above ground utilities - SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof - SSC No, 2 • Recessed entry - Deferred • Lot coverage - Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street - SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location - SSC No. 4 • Historic light - SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing - SSC No. 6 • Tree removal - SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use - Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use - SSC No. 8 • Terminal island (north end) - SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line - SSC No. 11 • Lighting - SSC No. 12 • Parking space length - Deferred • Parking spaces required - SSC No. 13 • Building elevations -SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans - SSC No. 15 36 18 2/14/2025 9. Provide a revised landscape plan showing the terminal island located between the parking lot and alley to the south a minimum of 5-feet wide and fulfilling one of the four options for screening within Eagle City Code Section S-2A-7(K)(2)la-di. The revised landscape plan shall be reviewed and approved by staff and one member of the Design Review Board prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. 2 Parking ta f:wd:ctpe Strip: n 1an11ccape ,trill shall is• Provided whoa a Parking lot i, located adjaaul ❑0 t public uldu of tray. 1'he landscaped ,trip shall serve to shield clew, of Parked cars 111 1v1ssu1,t 111010nst1, and pedos1rianr. and to rsnbh%II c.cltdimatimu :along i architecturally diverse buildings. which creates a pleasing. hanmooiwis appearance along 1< roadway. Fold NI options are provided for lilllillue this requirement: a Provide a ten hen 1 I Oh nail, I:uJscxpeJ .trip between the right of way and the parking ''.. lol.:lntl plane with a IIIIl11II111III of one ,bade nee and ion 111115lunhs par 111111y 1-11'e (351 linear fret of frontage. exdudin;: driveway opening,. I) . Provide an earth Berm of tinily niches 110" 1 minimum height (do nal exceed 3,1 slope widlia a len fool 1 Ind wide L udscaped gulp henvoon the right of way and the parking lot. and plalu with a minimum of one :hale are:nil lice 15, dmths par 1him' live 1 t51 huem f0M of Iroutnge. excl4Jitr„ driveway openings e. [hovel, a six knit 16'1 landscaped >irlp with a mulmmm 1111nc Inch 1311" 1 peach drop horn the tight of way to the lxarknlg lot. arxi plant with .1 minimum of ono IIWde tree and liee 151 rhnths per thine (vr 1351 lunar loot 01 Iranlaee. exeludul_ dlicewar opening•: d Provide a throe fond 13'1 high fence of noort. hack. doge. or lkrorail,: block ra concrete ;long e tilt a four Ito.[ tat) wide huulaceped snip between the tight of way gad the parking lop. and plant n 111111111111111 of one ,hale tree and lice 15) sltnlbs per thirty lice t.15) llneat fret 11 fromagc, excluding driveway openings 37 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors — Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley — SSC No. 9 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line — SSC No. 11 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Building elevations — SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 38 19 2/14/2025 SSC No. 10 10. Provide a revised landscape plan showing the addition of a terminal island north of the parking spaces located south of the building. The terminal island shall be a minimum of 5-feet wide and planted with one shade tree and shrubs. ground cover. or grass. The revised landscape plan shall be reviewed and approved by staff and one member of the Design Review Board prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. ECC 8-2A-7(K)(4), states that no parking space is permitted to be more than 60-feet from an interior landscaped area and an interior planter is required to be planted with one tree and shrubs, ground cover, or grass. 39 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors — Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley — SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) — SSC No. 10 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Building elevations — SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 40 20 2/14/2025 SSC No. 11 11. Provide a revised landscape plan showing the landscape buffer between the parking lot and east property line a minimum of 5-feet wide and planted with one shade tree and live shrubs per 35-linear feet. The revised landscape plan shall be reviewed and approved by staff and one member of the Design Review Board prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. ECC 8-2A-7(K)(3)(a), requires a 5-foot wide landscape strip between the parking lot and property line and planted with a minimum of one shade tree and five shrubs per 35-linear feet. Proposed: 3-foot, 2-inch buffer area planted with Blue Oat Grass and Skyrocket Junipers. 41 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors — Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley —55C No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) — SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line — SSC No. 11 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Building elevations — SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 42 21 2/14/2025 SSC No. 12 12. Provide a detail showing how the proposed light fixture will be shielded to direct all light downward and the source of the light not directly visible pursuant to Eagle City Code Section 8-4-4-2. The detail shall be reviewed and approved by staff and one member of the Design Review Board prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. Pursuant to Eagle City Code Section 8-4-4-2, all site and building lighting is required to be recessed or shielded to direct all light downward and the source of the light (including the lamp and any nonopaque material/lens covering the lamp) should not be directly visible by a person of average height standing on the property line of any public right of way. SF1 43 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors - Deferred • Above ground utilities - SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof - SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry - Deferred • Lot coverage - Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street -SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location - SSC No. 4 • Historic light - SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing - SSC No. 6 • Tree removal - SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use - Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use - SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley - SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) - SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line - SSC No. 11 • Lighting - SSC No. 12 • Parking spaces required - SSC No. 13 • Building elevations - SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans - SSC No, 15 44 22 2/14/2025 Parking Space Length Required length: 19-feet (may be shortened to 17-feet if the parking spaces abut a landscape planter) Proposed length: 17-feet (abut a planter that is required to be 5- feet wide but is only 3-feet, 2-inches wide 45 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors — Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley — SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) — SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line —SSC No. 11 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Building elevations — SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 46 23 2/14/2025 13. If the City approves the applicants request to pay a parking in lieu fee for two parking spaces, the applicant shall be required to pay S 11.400.00 [S5,400.00 X 2] to the City prior to issuance of a zoning certificate. -OR- If the City does not approve the applicant's request to pay a parking in lieu fee, the applicant shall be required to provide revised site and landscape plan showing an additional 2-parking spaces located on the site. The revised site and landscape plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Design Review Board prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. Number of Parking Spaces 9-parkin„ spaces 2-onstreet parking spaces 4-covered parking spaces 3-onsite parking spaces (2-compact) 11 -parking spaces (minimum) 4-covered parking spaces 2-onsite (residential) 1-guest parking space 4-conunercial parking spaces 47 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors — Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley — SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) — SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line — SSC No. 11 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 48 24 2/14/2025 SSC No. 14 14. Provide revised building elevations including all proposed materials and colors on the building. The revised building elevations shall be reviewed and approved by staff and two member of the Design Review Board prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. 49 Issues of Special Concern • Building design, materials, and colors — Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street —SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No. 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No. 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley —SSC No. 9 • Terminal island {north end) — SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line — SSC No. 11 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Building elevations - SSC No. 14 50 25 2/14/2025 SSC No. 15 15. Provide revised building elevations, floor plans, roof plan, and photometric plans that are stamped by a licensed architect. The plans shall be reviewed and approved by staff prior to the issuance of a zoning certificate. 51 Summary • Building design, materials, and colors— Deferred • Above ground utilities — SSC No. 1 • Cross section of roof — SSC No. 2 • Recessed entry — Deferred • Lot coverage — Deferred • Streetscape along East Idaho Street — SSC No. 3 • Bicycle rack location — SSC No, 4 • Historic light — SSC No. 5 • Metal roofing — SSC No. 6 • Tree removal — SSC No. 7 • Buffer between building and residential use — Deferred • Buffer between parking lot and residential use — SSC No, 8 • Terminal island between parking spaces and alley — SSC No. 9 • Terminal island (north end) — SSC No. 10 • Buffer between parking lot and east property line — SSC No. 11 • Lighting — SSC No. 12 • Parking space length — Deferred • Parking spaces required — SSC No. 13 • Building elevations — SSC No. 14 • Stamped plans — SSC No. 15 52 26 2/14/2025 End of Presentation 53 27 2/18/2025 MASTER SIGN PLAN FOR A MULTI -TENANT MIXED USE OFFICE (BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL)/RETAIL RESIDENTIAL BUILDING DR-2024-30 Eagle Design Review Board Meeting February 13, 2025 City Staff: Phone: E-Mail: Emily R. Falco, Planner II 208-939-0227 1 2 1 2/18/2025 3 Building Elevations FACE SIGN INSPIRATION BLADE SIGN INSPIRATION 4 2 2/18/2025 Color Renderings 5 Issues of Special Concern • Master Sign Plan Criteria — SSC No. 1 • Sign panel thickness/mounting — SSC No. 2 • Perpendicular sign thickness/mounting — SSC No. 3 6 3 2/18/2025 Issues of Special Concern • Master Sign Plan Criteria — SSC No. • Sign panel thickness/mounting— SSC No. 2 • Perpendicular sign thickness/mounting — SSC No. 3 7 Master Sign Plan Criteria I. Me u1111m'tr, .Hall be the hlaaes ry'.0 Nan I'ur Ilk Muhl... 1I I Cy, Ruildile: .Inkl.lenenl \h5ed 1'14• 0111,C 1M11h<, atnl plolrubmrll Retell Rrairl:4ot Ili dd og .Ala. .5i g11 Porn I1:.01,11 m Id. been e,tebli+ltnl Orr the 1rw1.11./41101 all e:a1 Ua. (lvrlmnwue will he !mob n,lenrnl.:ea1 ane n,wa,u1hvl:nut a Inregrrn,p1 !1441: 11111,1 la• 1.:m..u11 ev Im,rpm Imo enllwmwee al lht exp411 c n1 the 1rs1.ml, Gr. FR.U..4PPRn\'AI. N/'.VI'IRF\IF\15: I Ilwt ,t:1a,11h tegbire.lu,ulPrw.iprAgrplacl,Ik!:1 anlyine euul.I.4 rittiv,n al A J4.igh I.www,lgn app,e3bon a.enll:prnx l by em.yrthe 1:,1n m appmaal nnn: n,anaa„s a1an. Jull ha stekt ell to 11)e('ifs liu a=n'lu.rpl,vd.1F:n ler City r1u11ref le. 114 opyrolu1. lu e(. al ,un unlhn l.enlxen the I apk can Code :nut the clsmin y.fied luau:. the 11N11 redrmi,e rep(.. aha11a7ply Each e:lau 4,IRIu the \1nhi-le*41 \It\erl lb, Building mill be 'Nutted 10 lu,e a .4siym e, eqn:pplu.a..IAmutud xrh: the aplsu.,J of the hauling e'k,ebebs. All p.lnil. Mr hr3111'1 .ig11. .1 their I:4411e1n.rl .hall be 1Mauarl by tertall1 el Is. alsl01111e,.nhonito all ll..albuil1S1K.1:.J eh.0;1,11 rode r ae Theenkrie i lard: henWer. I. All 1114111.411s Old! be,hv,g,:af. r,ul,mlrled a:;.l 014.11r11 a I.•nam.s exp.+mc S'u eyw4d.,n,J1u( bsckctt 4nrlr:. ar 4111114 nl e11) lyre mill be peony art. %1 raceway: will IvpenhineAl All 11pss.13111m.Il:edcrnl.ltt. I rhnalav'.e..vd N4In1,W 1'. Inm.sl c Wile 1?n4.u11711e4L. R..5t'SIRF11, MCA I ION, DESIGN A\D (ONSIRI CMS 111, Nf:SS: I. I1n,k4l4 Well b1,m. 11191. a II, r>.4! hr.,x.l,a1e51.ru1,. r.„rrrh141n1 lel ?AM/ :4all I'47 RLl41: I lellnxa la,l. r'nlari h.:ur ill 5C1, d1nunainn'_ (. I.' ID ikt y.44all sole 1Pellv:ldn,l14l. 1 Ten. ced4.1.rp..1.1 font ezxwl 11. C. %IISM}.1.I.A1uARX R1:U('I110_41I:\Is: I 1 en. 444! be 1npm.:hk b r ,he opera.‘ 01,1ul1 +egn c T4,wa a:,! r144 eoce.1.a x111 be WI.M1v.nn aetie;n en:ix 1!,41 lag i:t.lnhnl:wtlµr, era..eee 1N.lmage. _ Lean 1r h:. repr,e.me shall he tegem,nlxre (ur.v4 M rmnknaue..enxr. repair ut tep'a:eme n1..va.1 me <h,.k,e etecaua1nn14 Jul! Ira• ryv111d 1n knT h,: nee .11 m mnrallvg nJ,'r m,l ell turbo, -bell be memeitml vd<.md:vau 1,um,!.111 ,tor 1v rc.+.l•11+Ir le.l a:n rry+w , w.0 np.'n I441rsy of.a 1 v.: 1'p.n let n4na 11MVen leas.1! ,,g11..m111y-?ha uaally ,nll all p.•u•1:ax11. et thet 4441gv 11.bl.rvx.n4111.n1141:4:6,r8x,e.rs4u, any nunvul lewd 1n e., eol 8:l'1 nl.:11141nr (rtl:,ea.,.hp. lepe•.414.41nv:brrl,l coax! lhr.mm,};n1:e,ule lee a l:w ol apposed ellll eeado. w;lI Ite.,lu,i, enlee.nl,unl.w:' ....b.. et uyy.n.,edagm nembe nx .rn:J oe ksapha lt,uw c..v:fonuipr x te.i.a of Inv h`.um. 11 II. SIGN 5A31P11:.5: 11s:1Jil:r Well -„ 1111,1.11 Mu lsn:_e V1,111.1 (4.4,1e,n l::1::., , F. SR:.\ LOCATIONS: Noah Or.. Fa„ p]r.arael 8 4 2/18/2025 qfri e Issues of Special Concern • Master Sign Plan Criteria — SSC No. 1 • Sign panel thickness/mounting— SSC No. • Perpendicular sign thickness/mounting — SSC No. 3 9 SSC No. 2 2. Provide details on how thick the flat sign panel is and how it will be attached to the building. The details shall be reviewed and approved by staff and one member of the Design Review Board prior to the issuance of a sign permit. rFI IIAt,i7 .4 BLADE SIGN ELEVATION FACE SIGN ELEVATION 10 5 2/18/2025 Issues of Special Concern • Master Sign Plan Criteria — SSC No. 1 • Sign panel thickness/mounting — SSC No. 2 • Perpendicular sign thickness/mounting— SSC No. 3 11 3. Provide a detail showing how thick the wood sign is required to be and a detail showing how the sign is to be attached to the building. The details shall be reviewed and approved by staff and one member of the Design Review Board prior to the issuance of a sign 131111it. 41 BLADE SIGN ELEVATION FACE SIGN ELEVATION 12 6 2/18/2025 Summary • Master Sign Plan Criteria — SSC No. 1 • Sign panel thickness/mounting — SSC No. 2 • Perpendicular sign thickness/mounting — SSC No. 3 13 14 7 2/18/2025 EMERGENCY SERVICES BUILDING FOR EAGLE FIRE STATION No. 4 DR-2024-78 Eagle Design Review Board Meeting February 13, 2025 Barbara A. Williams, Planner 208-939-0227 1 2 1 2/18/2025 3 4 2 2/18/2025 5 6 3 2/18/2025 7 Building Elevations 1, 1' FRONT (SOUTH-, 8 4 2/18/2025 9 111 Issues of Special Concern • Architecture and landscaping deferred to the Board • Roof plan showing mechanical unit locations and cross section • Roof material • Permeable pavers • Bicycle rack • Generator details 10 5 2/18/2025 Issues of Special Concern • Architecture and landscaping deferred to the Board • Roof plan showing mechanical unit locations and cross section • Roof material • Permeable pavers • Bicycle rack • Generator details 11 Building Architecture OUTHE 12 6 2/18/2025 Issues of Special Concern • Architecture and landscaping deferred to the Board • Root plan showing mechanical unit Locations and cross section • Roof material • Permeable pavers • Bicycle rack • Generator details 13 Roof Plan and Cross Sections — SSC# 2 FAG E FINE STATION 14 7 2/18/2025 Issues of Special Concern • Architecture and landscaping deferred to the Board • Roof plan showing mechanical unit locations and cross section • Roof material • Permeable pavers • Bicycle rack • Generator details 15 Roof material — SSC#3 ROOF Matenal Architectural Shingles & TPO Color t.iatte Black & White (Per Manufacturer') 16 8 2/18/2025 Issues of Special Concern • Architecture and landscaping deferred to the Board • Roof plan showing mechanical unit locations and cross section • Roof material • Permeable pavet • Bicycle rack • Generator details 17 Permeable Paver and Installation Pattern — SSC#4 18 9 2/18/2025 Issues of Special Concern • Architecture and landscaping deferred to the Board • Roof plan showing mechanical unit locations and cross section • Roof material • Permeable pavers • Bicycle rack • Generator details 19 Bike Rack — SSC#5 ❑ ❑ 20 10 2/18/2025 Issues of Special Concern • Architecture and landscaping deferred to the Board • Roof plan showing mechanical unit locations and cross section • Roof material • Permeable pavers • Bicycle rack • Generator details 21 Generator Details — SSC#6 PLAN SIDE ELEVATION FRONT ELEVATION 22 11 2/18/2025 Issues of Special Concern 1111111111111111111111111111 • Architecture and landscaping deferred to the Board • Roof plan showing mechanical unit locations and cross section • Roof material • Permeable pavers • Bicycle rack • Generator details 23 24 12 2/18/2025 Nagle Fire Station //4 — Lakemoor 2489 S THREE BRIDGES WAY EAGLE, IDAHO 83616 1 489 S n ncrr. I+RMGLS \\ w I(\(;I.H. II) 1110 81616 2 Site Photo- Facing West (Eagle Road) Site Photo- Facing South (E Colchester Drive) 1 2/18/2025 Sirc El Al TRASH ENCLOSURE 3 4 2 2/18/2025 Eir Floor Plans 5 Architectural S Prairie School II. hiukling dasym u lne. split face CML' blo& rtbttdmck. powder coated steel in a whittled tone of red. pre- y concreteI arched openings. and. Stu 1 t r des a smooth modem finish. Cra i n nal elements le curt shedopenings sod thept poscdmaterials. Il with prairie school aryl of fean a to blend the budding in with the urr u ling developments With II (21..I.IIII 2.1tory height of3 7 fiir the train center massing and 2 cataruirner 0-ass mr r s at ril ti" the budding usll nor rmlr blond with the southern new commensal development, but it will giro meld a striking mil of enmmernaland residential styles to compliment adjacent neighborhood m the east. 111 111 1I1.. _ 11� III 111 III. 6 1 1 1.17 i 1 IIn a 00 BB Et] t5 u nil 3 2/18/2025 SO1'II I I...\ I' 41a0 7 j ;," *are ' ••`, .. "" '"'»* '`=• ,M m •.ir� 4 ' r ( ;°'...��. '% �r ,`•y, -.- w f 9 ,, ry . �_ • ., - • a.,. -• ., Thank ° 0 ° Jo Method 208-989-0643 D Greer, PMAP you Architect NilETXO° l. 4