Minutes - 2024 - Design Review Board - 05/23/2024 - RegularDESIGN REVIEW BOARD
MINUTES
The Design Review Board met in regular session on May 23, 2024. Lindgren presiding.
1. CALL TO ORDER: Meeting called to order at 6:02.
2. ROLL CALL: SAYER, LINDGREN, MIHAN, GREER, Absent: MURPHY, GRUBB,
DUPERAULT.
3. CONSENT AGENDA: ALL CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS ARE CONSIDERED ACTION
ITEMS. Consent Agenda items are considered to be routine and are acted on with one
motion. There will be no separate discussion on these items unless a Design Review Board
member or City Staff requests an item to be removed from the Consent Agenda for
discussion. Items removed from the Consent Agenda will be placed on the Regular Agenda
in a sequence determined by the Rules of Order. Any item on the Consent Agenda that
contains written recommendations from the City of Eagle shall be adopted as part of the
Design Review's Consent Agenda approval motion unless specifically stated otherwise.
A. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for the Approval of DR-2013-19-MOD6
- Modification t the Eagle Tennis Center - Life Time: Life Time, represented by Jay
Sparks, is requesting design review approval to modify the Eagle Tennis Center
building by remodeling the existing 84,324-square foot building and constructing a
62,805-square foot addition to create a health club for the Life Time Club. The 10.98-
acre site is located on the north side of East Riverside Drive approximately 233-feet
east of South Edgewood Lane at 1650 and 1632 East Riverside Drive (Lots 1 and 2,
Block 1, Tennis Club Plaza Subdivision No. 1). (BAW)
B. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for the Approval of DR-2024-13 - Three
Building Wall Si2ns for Life Time Club - Life Time: Life Time, represented by Jay
Sparks, is requesting design review approval for three building wall signs for the Life
Time Club. The 10.98-acre site is located on the north side of East Riverside Drive
approximately 233-feet east of South Edgewood Lane at 1650 and 1632 East Riverside
Drive (Lots 1 and 2, Block 1, Tennis Club Plaza Subdivision No. 1). (BAW)
C. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for the Approval of DR-2024-14 -
Common Area Landscaping within Torrente Secco Subdivision - Thomas
Coleman: Thomas Coleman, represented by Brian Gan-ett with Brian Garrett
Architecture and Design, PLLC, is requesting design review approval for the common
area landscaping within Torrente Secco Subdivision (Phases 1-5). The 88.32-acre site
is located at the southeast comer of West Beacon Light Road and North Palmer Lane
between West Beacon Light Road and West Floating Feather Road at 6397 West
Beacon Light Road and 6868 West Floating Feather Road. (ERF)
D. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for the Approval of DR-2024-15 - Two
Subdivision Entry Features and Monument Signs for Torrente Secco Subdivision
- Thomas Coleman: Thomas Coleman, represented by Brian Garrett with Brian
Garrett Architecture and Design, PLLC, is requesting design review approval for two
subdivision entry features and monument signs for Torrente Secco Subdivision. The
88.32-acre site is located at the southeast comer of West Beacon Light Road and North
Palmer Lane between West Beacon Light Road and West Floating Feather Road at
6397 West Beacon Light Road and 6868 West Floating Feather Road. (ERF)
Sayer moves to approve the consent agenda. Seconded by Mihan.
ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES.
4. UNFINISHED BUSINESS: None.
5. NEW BUSINESS:
Mihan recuses himself from this application.
ACTION ITEM: DR-2024-07 - Common Area Landscaping within Amberlv
Ranch Subdivision - Core Building Company: Core Building Company,
represented by Fred Alexander, is requesting design review approval of the
common area landscaping within Amberly Ranch Subdivision. The 11.81-acre
site is located on the southwest corner of West Beacon Light Road and North
Ballantyne Lane at 2141 West Beacon Light Road and 2793 North Ballantyne
Lane. (BAW)
Travis Peny, Core Building Company, 3945 W. Well House Court, Eagle provides
an overview of the application and responds to questions from the Board.
City planner, Barb Williams provides an overview of the application and responds
to questions from the Board.
Lindgren moves to approve DR-2024-07 - Common Area Landscaping within
Amberly Ranch Subdivision with site specific conditions as presented with the
following modifications.
Site Specific condition #2: To restate that site specific condition #2, that the
Board recommends the City approve removal of tress and does not require
mitigation and no additional trees are required, thus strike the 2nd, 3rd and 4th
line items within that condition. All other items presented are recommended.
Seconded by Geer. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES.
Greer recuses herself from the following application.
B. ACTION ITEM: DR-2024-18 - Common Area Landscaping within Tierpointe
Subdivision — DRY Ventures: DRY Ventures, represented by Dave Yorgason with
Tall Timber Consulting, is requesting design review approval of the common area
landscaping within Tierpointe Subdivision. The 16.01-acre site is located on the north
side of West State Street approximately 3,300-feet west of North Linder Road at 5800
West State Street. (BAW)
Dave Yorgason, 2300 W. Oak Hampton Court, Eagle, provides an overview of the
application and responds to questions from the Board.
Greg Baer, 10674 N. Sage Hollow, Boise, provides an overview of the application
and responds to questions from the Board.
Jo Greer, 4240 W. Lovegood Lane, Meridian, provides an overview of the
architectural structures within Tierpointe.
City planner, Barb Williams, provides an overview of the application and responds
to questions from the Board.
Lindgren moves to approve DR-2024-18 - Common Area Landscaping within
Tierpointe Subdivision with site specific conditions as presented with the
following modifications.
Site specific condition #2: To read that Board recommends the city approves the
removal of trees and proposed mitigation. No additional trees are required and
thus strike the next three paragraphs within that condition.
With the addition of site specific condition #11 which recommends an open
fencing/fence line along lot 9 that fronts the pickleball courts to be an open fence,
similar to the wrought iron rail fence presented tonight in leu of the vinyl fence.
Seconded by Sayer. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES.
Greer recuses herself from the following application.
C. ACTION ITEM.: DR-2024-19 - Subdivision Entry Monument Sign for Tierpointe
Subdivision - DRY Ventures: DRY Ventures, represented by Dave Yorgason with
Tall Timber Consulting, is requesting design review approval of a subdivision entry
monument sign for Tierpointe Subdivision. The 16.01-acre site is located on the north
side of West State Street approximately 3,300-feet west of North Linder Road at 5800
West State Street. (BAW)
Dave Yorgason, 2300 W. Oak Hampton Court, Eagle provides an overview of the
application and responds to questions from the Board.
Dan Conlin, IE Signs provides an overview of the application and responds to
questions from the Board.
City planner, Barb Williams, provides an overview of the application and responds
to questions from the Board.
Lindgren moves to approve DR-2024-19 - Subdivision Entry Monument Sign for
Tierpointe Subdivision with site specific conditions as presented with the
following modifications.
Site specific condition #4: Add a little more depths to the caps at the book end
columns and to provide a horizontal cap that would more or less match, does not
need to, to at least compliment and match those caps that would distinguish the
stone and the textured metal only in the horizontal ledge condition, not the
vertical.
Seconded by Sayer. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES.
Amended motion.
Prior motion to be reviewed by staff and one member of the Board.
Seconded by Sayer. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES.
D. ACTION ITEM: DR-2022-39-MOD 1 - Modification to the Landscaping at
Affiance Jui Jitsu - Alexandre Paiva: Alexandre Paiva, represented by John Day
with Slichter/Ugrin Architecture, is requesting design review approval to modify the
landscaping for the Alliance Jui Jitsu building. The
0.16-acre site is located on the southwest comer of South Wooddale Avenue and
East Hill Road at 195 South Wooddale Avenue. (BAW)
John Day with Slichter/Ugrin Architecture, Boise, provides an overview of the
application and responds to questions from the Board.
City planner, Barb Williams, provides an overview of the application and responds
to questions from the Board.
Lindgren moves to approve : DR-2022-39-MOD 1 - Modification to the
Landscaping at Affiance Jui Jitsu -with site specific conditions as presented with
the following modifications.
Site specific condition #3: Provide a revised plan showing the six Norway Pine trees
removed and replaced with 30-caliper inches of deciduous trees or 72-feet of
evergreen trees or a combination of deciduous and evergreen trees. The revised
landscape plan shall be reviewed and approved by staff and one member of the
Design Review Board.
Seconded by Greer. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES.
Mihan and Lindgren recuse themselves from this application.
E. ACTION ITEM: DR-2016-34-MOD2 - Modification to the Master Sign Plan for
Retail One Subdivision - TPC Commercial, LLC: TPC Commercial, LLC,
represented by Zach Turner with Rennison Design, is requesting design review
approval to modify the master sign plan for East End Marketplace. The 15.5-acre site
is generally located on the east side of South Edgewood Lane between State Highway
44 and East State Street inclusive of 650 and 750 South Edgewood Lane, 1801 East
State Street, and 1780 and 1800 East State Highway 44. (BAW)
Walt Lindgren, Lindgren/Labrie Architeture provides an overview of the application
and responds to questions from the Board.
City planner, Barb Williams, provides an overview of the application and responds
to questions from the Board.
Greer moves to approve DR-2016-34-MOD2 - Modification to the Master Sign
Plan for Retail One Subdivision with removing conditions and not imposing any
other conditions.
Comment: The reasoning of accepting the application as is without the
conditions 2 and 3 or the heights is because of the master sign code and having
some latitude as far as allowing design supersede some of the height
requirements and the square footage.
Amended and seconded by Sayer. ALL AYES...MOTION CARRIES.
6. REPORTS:
A. Design Review Board: None.
B. Staff: City Planner, Barb Williams, provides an update regarding the items scheduled
for the next Design Review Board meeting.
7. ADJOURNMENT:
Hearing no further business, the Design Review Board meeting adjourned at 8:04 p.m.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED:
G��lo I/k7r
CHARLOTTE HUBINGER,
CLERK OF THE MEETING
APPROVED:
/2 -2N _)/
WALTER LINDGREN,
CHAIRMAN
6/18/2024
1
T ERPO
Eagle Design Review Board
May 23, 2024
NTE
➢ Introduce Design Review Team & Site
➢ 2 applications:
➢ Landscaping & Amenities (Building Architecture & Design)
➢ Monument Sign
TALL
TIMBER
C l)NSULTINU
2
IVY
Oz
j
1
6/18/2024
• 66 residential units
• Single-family detached homes
• Building new access road
Stonehart, which connects to
Mosscreek to the north
• Shares with future Brookstone
(ie Tierpointe 2)
3
Tierpointe + Brookstone (aka Tierpointe 2)
4
2
6/18/2024
Land
TALL
TIMBER
5
SCR p D Arran.
Amre
Usso Fen
rlo
( z
BAER o
➢ Over 4 acres open space (approx. 25% of site)
➢ Pickleball courts
➢ Dog Park
➢ Pedestrian -friendly separated sidewalks w/ street trees & Pathways
➢ Quality landscape berming along State Street & Stonehart
y Like Castlebury, Timberland and Countryside
TALL
TIMBER
] NI:
6
i
1Z
AERo
3
6/18/2024
TALL
TIMBER
CONS tr Nel
7
TIERPOINTE SUBDIVISION
Street Drainage
Facilities
riTALL itmt•
- • •
IETIMBER
• CONS,
8
71 ; _ _i c-----
! .i----
....
Earl
1111`i°
BA EA rr--71
--eeesM.r
Street Drainage
Facilities
orm
SAMPIII 3
4
6/18/2024
6/ 1...-:. 000o0000
0 i
0 . i
.. 0
0
0 g
00
0 0
o t;
0. 0
0 0
0
REVIEW LANDSCAPE PLAN
•
0 0 °
\€
rtrr FIEVIEW LANOSCAPE
I r
10
00
Tir 0 0
0 C:) ignY.
0 0 0 0 0
-------- -----
0 STATE STREET lAwncraec atm
x X.
trtr.v.
I North Half I
2
a
L 1
Tierpointe Subdivision
L2
South Half I
t
5
6/18/2024
-In
0-Series Size 1
Mi
6.4111114.11,,
• .
® I.NOESOM LIGHT DETAIL
11
5N7K;,:*.•1.
C.12‘, T,FIEE PLANTING DETAIL
PIFFLE FIALL ANN CHAN CNA FENCE DETAIL
12
Dog Park and
Streetlight Details
PirlsW...401CY
• a:
•
. /17,;VI
,
",/ iki7,irrlIVAEI'F var.
\ SMUG PLANTING OEIA.A. ® EGEENG DMA*"
L. UWiE
LL
4-411:W=
,
MEM•
® 5,1,011INNYIPIEVACY FENCE GAM
® FANGANO WROUGHT IPION FENCE
.5
0
71,
Wel 4
BAER
f Pickleball Courts,
Benches,
Fencing Details
L (next sheet)
0
6
6/18/2024
Fencing S
6' Wrouaht Iron Fence
Color: Black
- Interior common
areas
- Pickle ball courts
4' Wrouaht Iron
- Dog Park
1
6' Chainlink Fence
Powder coated Color: Black
- Pickleball Courts
13
FENCING PLAN
14
6' Vinyl Fence
Color: Tan
- Interior around lots
- Sewer Lift Station
- Request next to
Pickleball
6' Solid Concrete Fence
Color: Hickory Brown
- State Hwy 44
- Stonehart Rd.
•
/
sc+.I =wb
iAVE
TEE
PEN
LE
LE.
ZEE
, :OBS
ARE
' BE
'HICKORY'
Fencing Locations I
LANDSCAPE LEGEND
It
II ,•
ih 40' CLEAR MSION TRIANGLE
❑ ❑ 6' TALL SOLID WALL FENCE
6' TALL PRIVACY VINYL FENCE
—0-0-0-0— 6' TALL WROUGHT IRON FENCING
4' TALL WROUGHT IRON FENCING
6' TALL BLACK VINYL COATED CHAIN LINK FE
EXISTING TREES TO BE REMOVED
TREE KEY: S=SPRUCE, B=BIRCH
7
6/18/2024
TALL
(TIMBER
15
\T
twctures
M
Jo D Greer
O2Ui�C1 MANAGEMCNT AUCMrECtUNE PLANMNG
Archkecture Structures
Eagle Sewer District Lift Station
➢ Mailbox Structure
TALL
TIMBER
16
Jo U Grco
8
6/18/2024
TIERPOINTE SUBDIVISION
Mailbox Structure
Eagle Sewer
Lift Station
17
ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURE OVERVIEW
• MAILBOX (AREA/O.H. STRUCTURE)
• (1) W. SANDY CREEK STREET @
SIDEWALK
1 TALL
TIMBER
18
• PUMPHOUSE (EAGLE SEWER LIFT STATION)
• (1) W. MARBLE STREET @ COMMON LOT
• ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURES
•
9
6/18/2024
19
ism I II NA
Am -
TALL
TMBER
TIMBER LTIN1:
20
...WINO Wear,
.w�aae Ot sLL6
4,uY
Craftsman
We chose to use Craftsman style as the basis of design for the
Tierpointe landscape structures. Details of the Craftsman Style that
have been utilized in the design include:
• Wide, Overhanging Eaves
• Balconies and towers are absent
• Gabled roof lines
• Long sloping and wide roof line
• Square and simple design rather than ornate
• Wood materials are primarily board & batten
• Woodwork is dark colors
The design of the building and other amenities have a nice modern
twist on the traditional Craftsman Style. The color scheme and
materials of the structures have been designed to fit within current
market trends and fall within approved guidelines from the city and
input with staff. Overall, the materials fit into the style and help
create special points of interest throughout the neighborhood.
UM, W1.14re
SW7004 6x+rtw wµis
Pumphouse
Lift Station/Eagle Sewer District
10
6/18/2024
40A RD SEAITC N
IiARDIE SIMNG:
SW 7O44, 4 R,ZZ4E
GRAY
21
TALL
TIMBER
CONSULTING
Lighting
ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURES
FASCIA / SOFFIr:
]GA. EX1IRA WHITE
Mailbox
Structure
ARCHITECTURAL STRUCTURES
TALL
TIMBER
CONSULTING
22
•
11
6/18/2024
THANK YOU
Jo Greer, Architect
jo@methodpmap.com
23
Jo D Greer
LICENSED ARCHITECT
XDu METHDDPMAP.COM
(208)988-0643
PROJECT MANAGEMENT ARCHITECTURE PLANNING
Staff Report
Agree with staff report. Seeking clarification:
✓Solid vinyl fencing allowed adjacent to pickleball
court as shown
✓ #2 = Tree Mitigation approved as shown
✓ #3 = Overhead utilities across State 44
24
12
6/18/2024
RPONTE MonmeS
TALL
TIMBER
uc
25
26
gn
13
6/18/2024
CN,oLU
I.a.PNI,
urasma
PIaImI
,ISA:x.1 *A HAI EUI
r
27
28
SIDE DELUI
DOUBLE FACE I.tO`:UMENT'WITH HALO ILLUMINATED PAP, CHANNEL LE t } ENS•
Landscaping
around sign
10'-0'
It
s11
'1, a,QF
eMONUMENT SIGN LANDSCAPE EXHIBIT
10
SCALE'7-1'-0'
NOTES
CABINET -
FABRICATED FROM ALUMNUM PAINTED WITH A SW 7036 ACCESSIBLE BEIGE TEXTURED FIN.SH
FACES
ALUI NUM PANTED WITH A W Hod ACCESSIBLE BEIGE TEXTuREO F •RSH
REVERSE PAY -CHANNEL CORY-
FABRIGA-TEO WITH ALUMINUM FACES ALUMINUM RETURN: AND ACRYLIC BACKS FACES ANO
RETURNS ARE PANTED DORANOD:C BRONZE LETTERS ARE PEG MOUNTED FROM
ALUINUM EACE
ILLUMSNATION-
SYIIITE LED IIALO ILL UUNATION. U I. LISTED
STONE COLUMNS AND BASE
CULTURED STONEMOJAKE COUNTRY LEDGE510NE
CCRIA N EIYI$H EARS,
FABRICATED FROMA.UANUM :ANTED SW 7035 ACCESSIBLE BEIGE
SuPPORT-
01 LBS - 1.� b SHOY,11'RITH A a' STEEL P.PE SUPPORT
f'lAMVEDUL,MONOINEN1 �{;N
TaN1GC IIwC 1 dNM Nw[
viz
ISIEE WPRE SRC wtw677
14
6/18/2024
Staff Report -Monument Sign
✓Agree with staff report
29
Thank You
30
15
6/18/2024
31
TIERPOINTE SUBDIVISION
32
16
6/18/2024
Coordination to north
✓Working with adjacent developer to
north (utilities, transition, streets)
✓Same number of lots and similar lot
sizes adjacent to Mosscreek Sub
✓Same setbacks as Mosscreek (see DA)
✓Collaborating to build collector road
33
34
Mailbox Structure
17
6/18/2024
W. MARBLE ST.
REAR ELEVATION
LEFT ELEVATION
ELEVATION
••
SITE FLAN FRONT ELEVATION
35
Sewer Lift Station Building
taotaga
FLOOR PLAN.
2
18
6/18/2024
COMMON AREA LANDSCAPING WITHIN AMBERLY
RANCH SUBDIVISION
DR-2024-07
Eagle Design Review Board Meeting
May 23, 2024
City Staff:
Phone:
E-Mail:
Barbara A. Williams, Planner Ill
208-939-0227
1
2
1
6/18/2024
Landscape Plan
MACONLMMTRO.
-- Il,illil1Y111iiiL',
.' s • a •
3
3
Issues of Special Concern
• Landscaping deferred to the Board
• Tree removal and mitigation
4
2
6/18/2024
Issues of Special Concern
- • Landscaping deferred to the Board
• Tree removal and mitigation
5
Landscape Plan
6
3
6/18/2024
Issues of Special Concern
• Landscaping deferred to the Board
• Tree removal and mitigation
7
Existing tree inventory and proposed removal
The applicant is proposing to retain 30 of the trees and remove 6 of the trees from the site. The 6 trees identified to be
removed are ash (3). cotton+t ood (1). hone, locust (1). and maple (1) all of tt hich hate been identified as being in poor
condition. undesirable. or aolunteers.
8
4
6/18/2024
Tree mitigation — SSC#2
II the ('in approves the remo\ al of the trees and does not require mitigation. no additional trees are required.
-OR-
If the ('it\ approves the remo\al of the trees and does required mitigation. the applicant should be required to provide a
revised landscape plan sho\\ing an additional 1 IO-caliper inches of tree (55. 2-inch caliper trees) planted on site. The
re' iscd landscape plan shall he re\ ie\\ed and approved by staff prior to the submittal of a final plat application.
-OR-
If the City appro\ es the removal of the trees and does required mitigation. the applicant may opt to pay an in lieu fee into
the tree fund in the amount of S19.250.00 (110-caliper inches x $ 175.00 per caliper inch). The payment to the tree fund
shall be received b. the City prior to the submittal of a final plat application.
-OR-
An other combination of planting additional trees on site and/or a contribution to the tree bind as may be approved by the
:1 revised landscape plan and/or contribution to the tree fund shall he re\ iewed and approved and/or submitted to the
('its prior to the submittal of a final plat application or commencement of an construction;dernolition on the site.
liichever occurs first.
9
Issues of Special Concern
lo
• Landscaping deferred to the Board
• Tree removal and mitigation
10
5
6/18/2024
11
6
6/18/2024
G toy'
MODIFICATION TO THE MASTER SIGN PLAN FOR
EAST END MARKETPLACE
DR-2016-34-MOD2
Eagle Design Review Board Meeting
May 23, 2024
City Staff:
Phone:
E-Mail:
Barbara A. Williams, Planner III
208-939-0227
1
2
1
6/18/2024
Site Plan (Original and Proposed)
CST
3
1 SITE PLAN - ORIGINAL
,,1 SITE PLAN - PROPOSED MODIFICATION
Original CS-1 Monument Sign
CS-2.
TS ,
TSS,
ff TS,
CS 1
016.
AIOIITPIIIa:
FUTURE TENANT
FUTURE TENANT
Day view
L.1
ib U 'REAP
Night view
4
2
6/18/2024
Proposed CS-1 Monument Sign _Al
y#eiiir9 3Prn711
ArATiSS{
founfoinP[N
1)' chile Pub
PAR f1'ifORI.
Eagle Beag.e
Day view
5
6
4 preeppova
M
,xis mat
A
ir
I* Wit Sabi
PAMMORII
Eagle Beagle
araam Mall
Night view
1111111.11
• ewe DOWNWARD
H.V 0•10.M WATWn
;PHOTO CELL REO
3
6/18/2024
;�siva+l� ir�iia
7
Proposed CS-3 Monument Sign - new
8
4
6/18/2024
Original TS-1, 2, and 4 Monument Signs
9
Proposed TS-1, 2, and 3 Monument Signs
roc‘ YtTY STORE
10
5
6/18/2024
Proposed DD-1 Directional Wayfinding Signs - new
CS :I
Jsi
z
uilii '1.[rPi,1CC
axe('
arruraraltior
La1'1 75r-w'R
9r174. 671RJ1A'immamman
slfAR SU- HMW
11
Issues of Special Concern
• Height of the CS-1, CS-2, and T-1, T-2, and T-3 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Signage proposed on four sides of CS-1 and CS-2 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Area of CS-3 monument sign exceeds 60-square feet — SSC#2
• Directional — wayfinding signs exceed 6-square feet — deferred to the Board
• Landscaping around the base of CS-1 monument sign — SSC#3
12
6
6/18/2024
Issues of Special Concern
• Height of the CS-1, CS-1, anc 1-1, i -2, and T-3 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Signage proposed on four sides of CS-1 and CS-2 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Area of CS-3 monument sign exceeds 60-square feet — SSC#2
• Directional — wayfinding signs exceed 6-square feet — deferred to the Board
• Landscaping around the base of CS-1 monument sign — SSC#3
13
Height of signs — deferred to the Board
7 fw3I Sprmr!
MNTiSS{
founfoinP{N
ca-ve
Orbc
Pf'R:YSiORk
Ta9ie Beagle
LIQUOR STORE
Proposed 27' 3"
Permitted 25'
2' 3" of architectural
feature above top
tenant panel
C"a Vie°
�'r nor iJuU
Proposed 17' 3"
Permitted 15'
2' 3" of architectural
feature above top
tenant panel
Proposed 7' 9"
Permitted 6'
1' 9" of architectural
feature above top
tenant panel
14
7
6/18/2024
Issues of Special Concern
• Height of the CS-1, CS-2, and T-1, T-2, and T-3 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Signage proposed on four sides of CS-1 and CS-2 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Area of CS-3 monument sign exceeds 60-square feet — SSC#2
• Directional — wayfinding signs exceed 6-square feet — deferred to the Board
• Landscaping around the base of CS-1 monument sign — SSC#3
15
Proposed CS-1 Monument Sign — signage on 4
elevations —deferred to the Board
Eagle City Code Section 8-2A-
8(C)(2)(i) — Monument signs
are permitted to be double
faced.
16
9'FI%1 ail
n1ATiSSE
founfolnPfll
Or AAA,' Pub
PfR FY S ORI:
5 a9,e 3eagle
LIQUOR STORE
Day view
aim 11.
;- tW
Lk *art Sabi
mare mat I
ilEagte Beagle f
t'.1)MA
8
6/18/2024
Issues of Special Concern
• Height of the CS-1, CS-2, and T-1, T-2, and T-3 monument signs — deferred to the Board i
• Signage proposed on four sides of CS-1 and CS-2 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Area of LS-3 monument sign exceeds 60-square feet — SSC#2
• Directional — wayfinding signs exceed 6-square feet — deferred to the Board
• Landscaping around the base of CS-1 monument sign — SSC#3
17
Area of CS-3 — SSC#2
The area of CS-3 on the revised
plan date stamped 5-22-24 do
not exceed 60-square feet.
he Dcsi
Sara p
e issue
permu.
18
9
6/18/2024
Issues of Special Concern
• Height of the CS-1, CS-2, and T-1, T-2, and T-3 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Signage proposed on four sides of CS-1 and CS-2 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Area of CS-3 monument sign exceeds 60-square feet — SSC#2
• Directional — wayfinding signs exceed 6-square feet — deferred to the Board
• Landscaping around the base of CS-1 monument sign — SSC#3
19
E
Area of DD-1 Directional Wayfinding Signs exceeds 6'
square feet — deferred to the Board
Eagle City Code Section 8-2A-
8(C)(16 — Directional Signs
(0n Premises): Shall not
exceed 6-square feet in area.
REAR SIDE
FRONT
20
10
6/18/2024
Issues of Special Concern
• Height of the CS-1, CS-2, and T-1, T-2, and T-3 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Signage proposed on four sides of CS-1 and CS-2 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Area of CS-3 monument sign exceeds 60-square feet — SSC#2
• Directional — wayfinding signs exceed 6-square feet — deferred to the Board
• Landscaping around the base of CS-1 monument sign — SSCU3
21
Landscaping around the base of CS-1— SSC#3
The area of landscaping around
the base of CS-3 on the revised
plan date stamped 5-22-24 meets
the required 669-square feet of
landscaping requried.
3. Provide a revised landscape plan for sign CS 1 showi
minimum of 669 square feet of landscape
he monument sign. The revised lar
eveewcd and approved by staff and
s
around the -base of
scapc plan shall be
nc member of the Design
22
11
6/18/2024
Issues of Special Concern
• Height of the CS-1, CS-2, and T-1, T-2, and T-3 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Signage proposed on four sides of CS-1 and CS-2 monument signs — deferred to the Board
• Area of CS-3 monument sign exceeds 60-square feet — SSC#2 (could be deleted)
• Directional — wayfinding signs exceed 6-square feet — deferred to the Board
• Landscaping around the base of CS-1 monument sign — SSC#3 (could be deleted)
23
24
12
6/18/2024
SUBDIVISION ENTRY MONUMENT SIGN FOR
TIERPOINTE SUBDIVISION
DR-2024-19
Eagle Design Review Board Meeting
May 23, 2024
City Staff:
Phone:
E-Mail:
1
2
Barbara A. Williams, Planner III
208-939-0227
1
6/18/2024
Landscape Plan
3
Landscaping around base of monument sign
PLANT SCHEDULE MONUMENT SIGN
SMI BOL BOTANICAL NAVE (COMMON HWE
sdsurr
Ostle
Ia G I—Ia
IlNLS(PueiENNw.+.s..r.✓. Iv 1
4
2
6/18/2024
Monument Sign Elevation
TIERPOINTE
r
tatwrvir
• Landscaping and monument sign elevations deferred to the Board
6
3
6/18/2024
End of Presentation
7
4
6/18/2024
MODIFICATION TO THE LANDSCAPING AT ALLINACE
JuIJITsu
DR-2022-39-MOD1
Eagle Design Review Board Meeting
May 23, 2024
City Staff:
Phone:
ail:
Barbara A. Williams, Planner I1
1
2
1
6/18/2024
Site Plan
3
4
2
6/18/2024
Trees trimmed
5
Picture of trees that have been trimmed
6
3
6/18/2024
• Tree trimming deferred to the Board
7
End of Presentation
8
4
6/18/2024
East End Marketplace — Master Sign Plan
(DR-34-16 DR MOD)
Eagle, Idaho
1
RETAIL ONE SUBDIVISION VICINITY MAP
2
1
6/18/2024
East End Marketplace: SITE PHOTOS
1111111111111111111
TS-1
4
CS-3
\,1 SITE PLAN - ORIGINAL
TS.1
2
6/18/2024
5
MAT
:atmiuinPfN
u£ )tav out,
i. l.t
Ho OR STORE
6
SITE PLAN - PROPOSED MODIFICATION
3
6/18/2024
gegy
MNTiSS[
founiairPEN
Cae
11r ��Ilc ,lug
I.1 S i O R i.
3ea91e
LIQUOR STORE
CENTER SIGN 1(25')- FRONT ELEVATION (REAR. SIM.) CENTER SIGN 1125') . SIDE ELEVATION (TYP.)
S-1,..,� CS-1
AIM IF.
cs-1
SIGN
TYPICAL PLANTING PLAN
8
LL
PLANT SCHEDULE
ICE' BOTANICAL N,IE
COMMON NAYS
6Y Cow Gr Mrvooe
9pirau lavnalee'LI Ycua'
a Lln.nrel 9p lr.
A Design Renew MoAAlcaaon (or the
EAST END MARKETPLACE
Eagle. Idaho
if FaSeuni,2224
SPECIFICATIONS
PLANTING 912E MATURE SIZE
CaPll_R GOaERLSRARACOLES. Y!2,LQ
Cv Cm L�.b Tr.sei loafZ
HN r+wrcc.Ill. a'Su1l. I3. Coo'
[AAA O. O. DaylIlly
PA PrnNeun alopru-olex 'LIUUI. Bury' I CHI. • NV OL.
LIUII. L%05 dual 050.M 6...
3 Gel.
2 Gal
I CAL . WI OC.
3'Nel.a 3' AAA
2 .at. a 3 turd.
O' Vt.
II' het. a 2 AAA
2'Nit. a 3 aide
iu
RENNISON
CENTER SIGN I
25 PYLON
CS-1
4
6/18/2024
hATISSF
�o1�n�alnPtW
Caere
Otbr Pub
A Dawn Roalaw Modocalron for 150
EAST ENO MARKETPLACE
Eagle
Idaho
s.
CENTER SIGN 2 (15') - FRONT ELEVATION (REAR, SIM.) C CENTER SIGN 2 (15') - SIDE ELEVATION (TYP.)
C-2..... CS-2•.•.
CS-2
SIGN
TYPICAL PLANTING PLAN
10
PLANT SCHEDULE
iu
CENTER SIGN 2
15 PYLON
CS-2
KEY DOTANICAL N1010 RANTR.O SIZE 71A2U01E SZE
COMMON NAM
Z
E0'1 Euw •x'60w Win' iWI. 3'Igl. a 3'2.16. 14
m-min cisin eoaaooe y
Pi E•60.10 Uv1,03®11 Rroam Pivar' 2 60. I' NBL a 4' ele.
1.3
3010:00 PIIIw o o .
95 Spir y aarllW 'LIaO.c 1 W I, Z V.. x 1 6,10
5.O0.,,, Cn5FR5/ C.w.fwfFs/ PFRFIO11N a .416
6 JYF{21
10 FulEu eBw gucu�u'E:I}aY6090. OLZ0RI
HN IW.0 Y'ODmYgla]'uiGO rCi
0I o
S0011 D0 Oro Daylllly yT
LL Lava 119 119 L. 1011a 9IIly Dilly' 100 0 30' OL. D' Igt x IO" vaM CO
Dilly Dilly Lava/ Q
i W
ad
U 0.Ur
xlcoi
Owai;
5
6/18/2024
11
12
•
111111\11E1nd:
CS-3 CENTER SIGN 3 - WEST ELEVATION
CS.3 SENTER SIGN 3 - SOUTH ELEVATION
CS-3 CENTER SIGN 3 - REAR ELEVATION
6v1
:01
CS-3 CENTER SIGN 3- PLAN
A Devgn Ravfow Modr6c.on for the
• EAST END MARKETPLACE
Eagle. Idaho
15 FEBRUARY 2. ,Rev. 20,11
GENERAL NOTES
• ""‘""'"."
. 111=1.1
SPECIFICATIONS
OW
Z 1;
La a. t•
f—
< "
RENNISON
LOO1FICAIION
CENTER SIGN 3
CORNER SIDE
_CS-3
6
6/18/2024
CS-3
VA 0 OP
SIGN
TYPICAL PLANTING PLAN
13
14
PLANT SCHEDULE
KET BCTANIGAL N4`IE LANLRIG SIZE r'IATLRE SIZE
CRTIC I VYYE
!N
BH GIAW Grp Gan' 1 Cul
GraGamBoxuaotl
SIT Barbaro trvorgli in d Pllkr' 2 G.I. }' Fgt. V. t' ulb•
WEI* Pillar Marlowe,
Ce322iP_G9YERfeL 04490EOLS_ Etti,ALA
R: tw w g 21I�an' r E:IJ.F Bw Rrcu�
✓ N odlll• s'tra1:. W Oro
Bulk D• Cao B.ylllly
DD-1
5'oet a 5 ultlo CI
G.I. •yr' oc. k'Fat.v b'iW
I Gal. •A'GG.
SIGN
2
AL SIGNAGE LANDSCAPE PLAN
7
6/18/2024
TS-1 TENANT SIGN 1 -SIDE ITYP.)
TS-2 TENANT SIGN 2 - SIDE (TYP
15
TS-1
16
SIGN
9#'e4S9 Sporn
orn
OR VF 111•U
TS-1 TENANT SIGN 1 - FRONT 6 REAR (TYP.)
TS-2 TENANT SIGN 2 - FRONT S REAR (TYP.)
TS-2
TYPICAL PLANTING PLAN
PLANT SCHEDULE
•
SIGN
KEY BOTANICAL NAME PLANTING 512E SATIRE SIZE
CAI S.4NAME
9aRl@9
6M 06•0 'Gown 2 Gel. 3'1g1..3.le.
Ge.i Gee peru:eea
0112CO1D COVERS/GRASSES/ PFIWNSIALCV Carew*. v•rtIcIllake 'ZA6,110'
P00.011 cvew 91100. 'SIN.'
BUM SW row.
Le..rdle .rgwlllolle Dilly D113j'
O.5 Dilly L.v.� d
P.160.3n.lep r..eld0e'LIrW play'
LAW My WwT r..4m Gress
LL
PA
!Gel. • OC. 12- 1g1.. M'ad.
I Gal. a 36 OG IC• 1631.. I0 .IAN
I GIN . 36. OG. i]• Igt. n b• 013.
I Gel.. 36" OC 2' 1.g1.. 3 We.
A Dealgn Review Modification for the
EAST END MARKETPLACE
Eagle. Idaho
SPECIFICATIONS
iu
t
•U_I
Z <
RENNISON
TENANT S/61.16 2
51te61E800:RLE
TENANTS
13.
TS-1/TS-2
8
6/18/2024
•
I
TS-3 TENANT SIGN 3 . SIDE (TYP )
REAR 50E
17
TS-3
SIGN
NV VT
WALL N.4.5010 MIS Afid•
•o- 44_ ummlup. 111611111. MAP. pawl
TYPICAL PLANTING PLAN
PLANT SCHEDULE
TS-3 TENANT SIGN 3 - FRONT & REAR (TYP.)
FRONT
DD-1 DIRECTIONAL DISPLAY
BOTANICAL NAME PLANT.. WM MATL DUE
COYTION NAME
ANS.S5
ST N. .00erell Ad 2 51.1. 2' iatela
Us... Pillar Par....5
OSWALD CSVERS, 004BSE5/ PPSE,NIAL5
PA P•mlawar. alopeckrolder dr.,' (2.1. • NA '' Oa 1.
Lott. 5-,ny FoLnuln
CV varlIcIllina 'Zs=
ZIgn. ov•adwar TI
18
1 CUL • M. It' FRL le• .AS
A Dawn Renew Nlochficnoon far the
EAST END MARKETPLACE
Eagle. Idaho
SPECIFICATIONS
•
D0.1 SPECIFICATIONS
r(1.... •
SITE MASTER PLAN
.06.1.111,11
RENNISON
11011FICATION
TENSO SON 1
SPECTIONAL
DISPLAY
"7.
TS-3/DD-1
9
6/18/2024
s�E
19
FRONT 6 REAP
2 SIGN ILLUMINATION • TENANT SIGN (TYP.)
FRONT REAR
3SIGN ILLUMINATION -CENTER SIGN (TYP.)
A oeNge Ruvww Moddolwn for ma
EAST END MARKETPLACE
Eagle. Mello
1 SIGN ILLUMINATION -CENTER SIGN 3
u�
Oa 1.1001FICATKIN
3,314
ILLIANNIMonj
Site Specific Condition #1
Condition 1: The following shall be the master sign plan criteria for the business located
within East End Marketplace: East End Marketplace Master Sign Plan This criterion has been
established for the mutual benefit for all tenants. Conformance will be strictly enforced, and
any non -conforming or unapproved signs must be removed or brought into conformance at
the expense of the tenant.
RespDnse.
Will comply.
Site Specific Condition #2
Provide a revised sign elevation of the subdivision monument sign (CS-3) showing the
square footage of the sign does not exceed 60-square feet. The revised sign elevation shall
be reviewed and approved by staff and one member of the Design Review Board prior to
the issuance of a sign permit.
Will comply. Please see revised sheet CS-3_CENTER SIGN 3 for modified sign size and
LANDSCAPE_SHEET 4 for modified planting area for CS-3.
20
10
6/18/2024
cs_3 TESTER SIGN 3 - WEST ELEVATION
CS-3 CENTER SIGN 3 - SOUTH ELEVATION
CS-3 CENTER SIGN 3 - REAR ELEVATION
21
CS-3SIGN
• :;,!:
•
eLL
cs_3 CENTER SIGN 3 - PLAN
PLANT SCHEDULE
KEY BOTANICAL NA,
OCrIllai NAM
MITINCia
BOI Bum. Zatimm Gan.
.aan Gam Boxwood
DT BarborIa 14hnor4 PIller'
Heleonel railler Carberry
GSCND_CCIVELRSEGS.A.SOEOLIMIRENNIAL9.
PO FO•LLIC• OV,Id oatma Baas,
ENVOI 51acLAN
Heneroo•Illa ',hell. Le Oro
Otella De Oro DaylIlly
OMAR allei IL /Ala • IMAM
TOTAL LAPADK-Ael ILIACIAMOL • LA3 3 • lee be
TYPICAL PLANTING PLAN
22
DD-1
A Design REL./WM...AAA Br the
EAST ENO MARKETPLACE
Eagle. Wail°
IEBAUARY 212-11., NWT Abe
GENERAL NOTES
SPECIFICATIONS
PLANTINS sla MAIIME IKTZ
Ga 1. • 3..
SIGN
TOTAL Le...No.+ RAILII.r."'L :A' • SI
LiMAGAB LANNI
leibODGICATON
CENTER SIGN 3
CORNER SIDE
CS-3
1 lip
ilij 1 ,,ki,
3' egt, a S. ebbs i 0 4
3' het 2' LIde
15
153 2' wIcle
6
LANDSCAPE PLAN
a .4
E,'F'cfi
ow< 11
VICO 01 .
II
11
6/18/2024
Provide a revised landscape plan for
sign CS-1 showing a minimum of 669-
square feet of landscaping around the
base of the monument sign. The revised
landscape plan shall be reviewed and
approved by staff and one member of
the Design Review Board prior to the
issuance of a sign permit.
Will comply. Please see revised
LANDSCAPE_SHEET 2 for modified
planting area for CS-1.
23
Site Specific Condition #4
A sign permit is required prior to the
installation of any signs on this site.
Will comply.
Site Specific Condition #5
Provide a copy of the electrical permit
for the sign installation prior to issuance
of a sign permit.
Will comply.
24
TYPICAL PLANING PLAN
Q
PLANT SCHEDULE
SoL
12
6/18/2024
East End Marketplace — Master Sign Plan
(DR-34-16 DR MOD)
Eagle, Idaho
25
13
Go gle Maps Eagle, Idaho
2511 E Hill Rd