Loading...
Minutes - 2023 - Design Review - 07/13/2023 - RegularDESIGN REVIEW BOARD MINUTES The Design Review Board met in regular session on July 13, 2023. 1. CALL TO ORDER: Grubb calls the meeting to order at 6:00. Grubb presiding. 2. ROLL CALL: GRUBB, SAYER, DUPERAULT, LINDGREN, MERRILL, MIHAN, GREER. Absent: Duperault. A quorum is present. 3. CONSENT AGENDA: ALL CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS ARE CONSIDERED ACTION ITEMS. Consent Agenda items are considered to be routine and are acted on with one motion. There will be no separate discussion on these items unless a Design Review Board member or City Staff requests an item to be removed from the Consent Agenda for discussion. Items removed from the Consent Agenda will be placed on the Regular Agenda in a sequence determined by the Rules of Order. Any item on the Consent Agenda that contains written recommendations from the City of Eagle shall be adopted as part of the Design Review's Consent Agenda approval motion unless specifically stated otherwise. A. Minutes of June 22, 2023. (CSH) B. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for the Approval of DR-127-04 MOD2 — Modification to a Multi -Tenant Office/Restaurant Building and Site, Including the Addition of a Cover for the Patio — BB One, LC: BB One, LC, represented by John Day with Slichter/Ugrin Architecture, is requesting design review approval to modify a multi -tenant office (business and professional)/restaurant building to include a cover over a portion of the existing patio and to modify the entrance to the restaurant. The 2.166-acre site is located on the southwest corner of South Rivershore Lane and South Eagle Road at 775 South Rivershore Lane (Lot 1, Block 1, Channel Center Subdivision). (BAW) Merrill moves to approve the consent agenda as presented. Seconded by Sayer. ALL AYES ... MOTION CARRIES. 4. UNFINISHED BUSINESS: None. 5. NEW BUSINESS: A. ACTION ITEM: DR-31-23 - One Subdivision Entry Monument Sign for Molinari Park Subdivision - GWC Capital: GWC Capital, represented by Landon Northey, is requesting design review approval for one subdivision entry monument sign for Molinari Park Subdivision. The 23.06-acre site is located on the south side of East Plaza Drive approximately 300-feet east of the intersection of South 2" d Street and East Plaza Drive. (ERF) Lindgren and Milian recuse themselves from this application. Jim Milian, South Beck and Baird, 2002 S. Vista Avenue, Boise, provides an overview of the application and responds to questions from the Board. City Planner, Emily Falco, provides and overview of the application and responds to questions from the Board. Grubb moves to approve DR-31-23 with the site specific and standard conditions as written. Seconded by Sayer. ALL AYES ... MOTION CARRIES. B. ACTION ITEM: DR-32-23 - Three Halo Illuminated Building Wall Signs and One _Monument Sign for Premier Storage - Eagle Highway Storage dba Premier Storage: Eagle Highway Storage dba Premier Storage, represented by Terry Brown with Lytle Signs, is requesting design review approval for three halo illuminated building wall signs and one monument sign for Premier Storage. The 6.41-acre site is located on the south side of West State Street approximately 560-feet west of the intersection of South Payette Way and West State Street at 1653 West State Street. (ERF) Terry Brown, Lytle Sign Company, 2070 E. Commercial Street, Meridian provides an overview of the application and responds to questions from the Board. Rob Martin, 1250 E. Iron, Iron, Eagle, owner of the project introduces himself and responds to questions from the Board. City Planner, Emily Falco, provides and overview of the application and responds to questions from the Board. Grubb moves to approve DR-32-23 with the following site specific and standard conditions as written with the following modification. Site specific condition #6: Provide a revised landscaping plan showing variation in planting location and to include evergreens to provide interest in winter to be approved by staff and one members of Design Review Board. Seconded by Merrill. ALL AYES ... MOTION CARRIES. C. ACTIONITEM: DR-33-23 - Multi -tenant Office Building in Lakemoor Subdivision No. 8 — DRB Investments: DRB Investments, represented by James Marsh with CSHQA, is requesting design review approval to construct a new two (2) story, 15,500-square foot office (medical/dental and business/professional) building. The 2.329-acre site is located on the southeast corner of East Eagles Gate Drive and North Eagle Road at 79 East Eagles Gate Drive (Lot 1, Block 10, Lakemoor Subdivision No. 8). (BAW) Jim Marsh, CSHQA 200 W. Broad Street, Boise, provides an overview of the application and responds to questions from the Board. City Planner, Barb Williams, provides and overview of the application and responds to questions from the Board. Grubb moves to approve DR-33-23 with the following site specific and standard conditions as written with the following modifications. Site specific condition #11: Provide specifications on the mortar to be approved by staff and two members of the Design Review Board. Site specific condition #12: Provide revised trash enclosure details showing a gate on trash enclosure for the man door section to be approved by staff. Site specific condition #13: Applicant has the option to do stack or bond for the masonry of the building to be approved by staff and one members of Design Review Board. Seconded by Merrill. ALL AYES ... MOTION CARRIES. D. ACTION ITEM.- DR-34-23 - Master Sign Plan for a Multi -tenant Office Building within Lakemoor Subdivision No. 8 - DRB Investments: DRB Investments, represented by James Marsh with CSHQA, is requesting design review approval for a master sign plan for a multi -tenant office (medical/dental and business/professional) building. The 2.329-acre site is located on the southeast corner of East Eagles Gate Drive and North Eagle Road at 79 East Eagles Gate Drive (Lot 1, Block 10, Lakemoor Subdivision No. 8). (BAW) Jim Marsh, CSHQA 200 W. Broad Street, Boise, provides an overview of the application and responds to questions from the Board. City Planner, Barb Williams, provides and overview of the application and responds to questions from the Board. Grubb moves to approve DR-34-23 with the following site specific and standard conditions as written with the following modifications. Site specific condition #4: Remove the words "to be a running pattern." Strike that. Site specific condition #5: Provide a revised elevation with the correct property address to be approved by staff. Seconded by Merrill. ALL AYES ... MOTION CARRIES. 6. REPORTS: A. Design Review Board: None. B. Staff. None. 7. ADJOURNMENT: Lindgren moves to adjourn. Seconded by Grubb. ALL AYES ... MOTION CARRIES. Hearing no further business, the Design Review Board meeting adjourned at 7:31. RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED: 1111'711� o� CHARLOTTE HUBINGER, CLERK OF THE MEETING APPROVED: RO ERT G UBB, CHAIRMAN 7/25/2023 7/25/2023 3 Molinari P a r k 1 MONUMENT SIGN �" m ELEVATIONS PLANT SCHEDULE O'�lM Mre+mow •u 4 EKHIBITT&-CONCEPT PLAN 6MONUM,ENT SIGN n F-- —�PLAN VEW CALLOUT LEGEND r ~ LL A M��. SOUTN ma ItECK1 ��+ r 7/25/2023 SPECIFIOATIQNS- MAIN STRUCTURE IS CORTEN STEEL WITH RUST PATINA FINISH 'MOLP AR PARW AND HORIZONTAL LINE WORK IS ROUTED FROM — ACRYLIC PAINTED MATTE SILVER. STUD MGUNTED-V OFf GACKGRGUNO. (a) EKTERHAL GROUND LIGHTS ARE PAR GK WHITE LED FLOOD UGHTS UY OTHERS. "]GODk MA%. J STEEL PIPE SUPPORT REQUIRED. 2T x 2 W xND FOOTING REOUIREO a-T • T SNYx I.d'D CONCRETE PAD WA' YD. CONCRETE REOUIREO, PROPOSED PHOTO NOTTO SCALE 7 OP_L • .7 � kc�,v �.. w.uruu.a W=iY65eAFSETY_ SIDE VIEW WN- FASE_FnERgAUAf�0001L.L�MII� TEO_M9IUMEtlI SCALE;(' _L'y_ 0 o FV. 0 5 .�s�s"-�Y�s `"s.,i I ,lei'- I � �' i��t -•::o �•'- --- :�`� '.X� � ` � ,Y fir,. i V2!, f Questions 0 3 7/25/2023 7/25/2023 FRONT VIEW NOTES: 3 m M o I i n a r P a r k 2 7/25/2023 5 PLANT SCHEDULE NDTEsaI�.'�, KEV BOTANICAL NAME PLANTING MATURE SIZE CLASS COMMON NAME SIZE SHRUBS SEE DETAIL4M12.0 e Junlpe- hOmm�laln Tilde Crtp 6 Gal. T hgI. X 6 Wi Blue Chip hx,mr t` r PhysOcapus apuli!OFous'SeawarG S Gal 6' hgL x 6 vide V Suovner Wine Mneomk GROUND COVERS) GRASSE&PERENNIALS SEE DETAIL 3.12A_ Calam X aaadlaa FoT I GaI, 6 hgL x 3 wide d-2 Kan Foe�Mer Dwdn Feather G255 F—" h i ) PhIOX wW1aW..Can$tge o. - IGaI. B'h91.xJ'WWII 2 i� I c'l�! PLAN VIEW CALLOUT LEGEND O 40' VISION TRIANGLE O2 EXISTING CONCRETE VAULT OJ EXISTING POWER BOX 4D MONUMENT SIGN n LAVOUTP.O.B. 3 Issues of Special Concern • Subdivision Entry Monument Sign — Deferred to the Board • Ground mounted light fixture cutsheets — SSC No. 1 Subdivision Entry Monument Sign • Subdivision Entry Monument Sign — Deferred to the Board • Ground mounted light fixture cutsheets — SSC No. 1 Subdivision Entry Monument Sign I L SSC No. 1 Fl* Subdivision Entry Monument Sign — Deferred to the Board • Ground mounted light fixture cutsheets — SSC No. 1 SSC No. 1 Summary • Subdivision Entry Monument Sign — Deferred to the Board • Ground mounted light fixture cutsheets — SSC No. 1 7/25/2023 13 \ t 1 `�1 , 1 Al, -t 3. jet L t� 'ham K� Yfi Apw� -%ANN. IM BUILDING COLORS TBD g'-p- 6'-2- 1 TOP CAP: ALUMINUM CONSTRUCTION PAINTED TO MATCH BUILDING (TBD) EMC: D/F 10MM FULL COLOR 98 X 192 PIXEL MATRIX 3' 1.8-X 8' 3.6- VIEWING AREA UPPER CABINET. ALUMINUM CONSTRUCTION 31SO. TUBE ACCENTS PAINTED DURANODIC BRONZE LOWER CABINET: ALUMINUM CONSTRUCTION PAINTED TO MATCH BUILDING (tBD) 12'-0' ={ 11 a3 sa Fr. 60 SQ. FT 185SO FI 1 D/F ILLUM MONUMENT SIGN LOGO: REV. PAN CHANNEL LETTERS C :3 2' ALUMINUM RETURNS /ALUMINUM FACES PAINTED DURANODIC BRONZE INTERNAL WHITE LEO HALO ILLUMINATION CLEAR POLVCARBONATE BACKS MOUNTED TO LOWER CABINET .11 1/2' STANDOFFS BASE CAP: ALUMINUM CONSTRUCTION PAINTED TO MATCH BUILDING (TBD) O BASE CULTURED STONE FINISH TO MATCH BUILDING (TBD) t STEEL POLE AND CONCRETE FOOTING FOOTING IS ON SLANTED GRADE O ILI- PREMIERE STORAGE OF EAGLE HATCH DESIGN BUILDING MATERIALS, ARCHITECTURE I- SAMPLES AND COLOR BOARD i _ WAINSCOT MSI STACKED STONE PANEL "ROMAN BEIGE" BRONZE TINTED - -- TRANSLUCENT GLAZING ) 1 PER WINDOW MANUF. BODY STUCCO SMOOTH CAST IN PLACE "MODERATE WHITE° CONCRETE METAL ROOF PANEL MBCI ULTRA-DEK "GALVALUME° METAL PARAPET CAP SMOOTH "BURNISHED SLATE" METAL ROOF PANEL MBCI BATTENLOK "BURNISHED SLATE" WINDOW TRIM ANODIZED ALUMINUM "BLACK" METAL WALL PANEL MBCI PBR 'ALMOND" 4r1� (`nkknfii llecnccnr lTsmay4auur5enenWevika4py�hemanlrAmrelmopprgsNanilaku.pemalnkv<rtaMr.pml.wnTatappuronVdamaymeYormsy aer�k zai•Y � .L Fdakre ayM1v ' Legend R.,k.d Roads (8.000-24,000 wra:.tao na4++an.n� wr PaM1 M Ciy L mis ❑ T.—Nps Secdons ❑ Ca ❑ Parceh -a ,DDO.Ada ® am. ❑ e _ Mw. _ rosler.DeOAdaONw ❑ Gv _ 5/a2023 io�i w Mate btreet 05o p0 Box 3 Eagle ID 83616 T.. x3 kn onnm ii ff PLANT SCHEDULE =16 c FDN 1-M-1-21-MEIM ii! ME H LAO—j ■ n 0 "Op BULDING IN CT (-- 8 O. A 24 o -PK LA 2 10 gw ,gM.LONUMF=N=T.Sl.11 LANDSCAPE EXHIBIT W LL w a10 MONUMENT SIGN - ELEVATION "A" SX-1.5 10'-3 3/4" �r I?remier L STORAGE SQ FT 510 AGFr STORAG SIMULATED NIGHT VIEW TO SUHVEV REQUIRED DEMONSTRATE ILLUMINATION SIDE VIEW ACUMINATED REV. PAN LETTER SETS - OUANTRV 2 2"ALUMINUM RETURNS w/ALUMINUM FACES PAINTED DURANODIC BRONZE INTERNAL WHITE L.E.D HALO ILLUMINATION CLEAR POLYCAABONATE BACKS MOUNTED TO BUILDING WALLS W 1 12" STANDOFFS �si'cHsl 10'-3 314' !T 'premier � STORAGE [ SIDE VIEW ILL UMINATED REV PAN ETTER SETS -QUANTITY 1 2' ALUMINUM gETURNS w/ ALUMINUM FACES PAINTED DURANODIC BRONZE INTERNAL WHITE L.E.D HALO ILLUMINATION CLEAR POLYCARSONATE BACKS MOUNTED TO BUILDING WALLS w/ 1 12' STANDOFFS THREE HALO ILLUMINATED BUILDING WALL SIGNS AND ONE MONUMENT SIGN FOR PREMIER STORAGE DR-32-23 Eagle Design Review Board Meeting July 13, 2023 City Staff: Emily R. Falco, Planner II Phone: 939-0227 E-Mail: Vicinity Map 7/25/2023 7/25/2023 —._T-8'2d� I 1 5.2•� . ba' �e "N VlP. ! 11 IS�n b80 SO. FT 'premier ,, F L STORAGE a T 5 ■ J._ 2 0,06000©00000 ■ ■ PROPOIED BUILDING T...I ■ 14le i,Pe®000 ■ 24 PK io ■ _ M R TCP LAs KUAruM corrNucrroN vnnitED tD MAtal euLDrx3 (Bq £MC' DF iDMM FU1 COLdi %NtiQ PU�LMNW% ] td'X63d'NflYXG fJ1EA I.PPEP GB7IFC (bNSiHUCiN)N ]'$O. TLBEALCEIAS PNItFD OUI W IXYG BHCHLE LCWEN CAFAIET. KWHIH fGNSTHUCMIN i'Nt1Flf TO IMTOI BIRDNG (ISDI PLANT SCHEDULE c.uour NDTE]iQ_�• .� �HR PLANTIN Loco- HEv. 0.AN LH.VmEL LETTEAB C� 'KUMNUM 0.ETUPA9 wIKUlAMUM fACE9 -N1ED OUW.ELE BRONII XfiFICML W W TE l.E. D HKO I W 11.6NATNk1 MIJN DTOMBOR NET MVJNTED TO LONE0. GBMETw/ 1 12' SLwppFFS BRSE CAn: KV W HUTA CONSTHULTNYI f]V MEO TO IMTCH BUIOXIG (TtlDI E: CULlUHEO STCNEFINISH i01MTCH BULUFiO jltlDi STEEL POLE AM QJNG�lE f00TBNI FODI W 015 O.N ]UNTED OMOE f�� Q f-� 3 Issues of Special Concern • Sign design, materials, color — Deferred to the Board • Automated sign — SSC No. 1 • Monument sign colors — SSC No. 2 Sign design, materials, and colors • Sign design, materials, color — Deferred to the Board • Automated sign — SSC No. 1 • Monument sign colors — SSC No. 2 7/25/2023 10 7/25/2023 11 12 7/25/2023 13 14 7/25/2023 15 MASTER SIGN PLAN FOR A MULTI -TENANT OFFICE (MEDICAL/DENTAL AND BUSINESS/PROFESSIONAL) BUILDING A' DR-34-23 Eagle Design Review Board Meeting July 13, 2023 Vicinity Map X City Staff: Barbara A. Williams, Planner 11 Phone: 939-0227 E-Mail: 00 7i City Staff: Barbara A. Williams, Planner 11 Phone: 939-0227 E-Mail: 00 7i Landscape Plan East and West Building Elevations West East 7/25/2023 7/25/2023 7/25/2023 10 7/25/2023 11 12 Issues of Special Concern • Monument sign landscaping • Punch through acrylic graphics not exceeding uv icl< pa tern ail we 1,11011ument sig; Brick pattern on monument sign — SSC#4 Issues of Special Concern • Monument sign landscaping — SSC#2 • Punch through acrylic graphics not exceeding %2" — SSC#3 • Brick pattern on the monument sign — SSC#4 End of Presentation _ rr i ti � E � i �� 1 flay r Y .�� + �,. 1{ DRB Investments, LLC ---- - --- - --- . . ......... . . . ...... - ---- - - -------------- - - ----------------- - ----- — ---------------- 41* . . . . . . . . . . . . q-s- ............ r-i-io -- -------------- -- FUTURE DEVELOPMENT - -------- — ------ --- ---------- 7 IS FUTURE 35 IORY 011Irl BUILDING EK - ---- ----------- ----------- — — ------ -------- — ------ — — ---------- - — -------- 23017 Eagles Gate View 04113f23 11 I-T SFEET NOTES: n I L CONCEPT SITE PLAN DESIGN REVIEW I SPIO CSHGA 23017 C & 0 Development, Inc PLANT SCHEDULE P LIM LL—. RM MIA M— IF sow— Ir—* —M Eagles Gate View Office 104/12/23 PROJECT INFORMATION LANDSCAPE 0.EOUIREMENTS WDF 9�4 WT—.— LANDSCAPE LEGEND ---------- — -- CALLOUT NOTES LANDSCAPE PLAN Design Review I pg. L ME 0 • DRB Investments, LLC I Eagles Gate View 1 04/13/23 WEED ABATEMENT NOTES' TREE PROTECTION NOTES: 23017 IRRJG TION NOTES: pun vIEw SECnpI NOTES' �GROUNDCOVER PLANTING I r:RRCS 2�PLANTER BED CUT EDGE ` =7- NOTEs� anm.r�r.w... n SHRUB PLANTING...- `ry .-. r,IZTREE PROTECTION DETAIL NOTES w.�Aiw .annurr�u wr 5 DECIDUOUSTREE 1PLANTINGMroro,„......,�. wer,+s LANDSCAPE NOTES AND DETAILS L02 CSH9,4 C — �.� .. C 9 �, oaq SOUTH ELEVATION .............. 5 .oc.no. q 3 xa scx..a 2 - -- __,; 23017 DRB Investment,, LLC I Eagles Gate View I anana _c EAST ELEVATION V�OR�TH ELEVATION q WEST ELEVATION 4,n , r MATERIALS 8 FINISH M SCHEDULE: 4 u.rmui �raMrc-aon M u �aoareama< ELEVATIONS DESIGN REVIEW I SDSI =. DRB Invesunenu, LLC ( Eagles Gate View 04113a3 I I I I I I I I I i::! ........... -- ------------------{" -------------- - _ -- I -- ---4------------I-------------{-- I I I I ---------- I -� 1 I I I I Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" FLOOR PLAN LEVEL 1 23017 DE51GN REVIEW SD21 ORB Investments, LLC Eagles Gate View 04/13/2023 - - — - — - — - — - — -- -- — - --- — - — - - — - — - — - - - — A r -,,I ------------ ------ --T ------------- ------ - ----T --------- ----- ------ ------------- Scale: 3116" = V-O' FLOOR PLAN LEVEL 2 23017 DESIGN REVIEW 13'-4" a J N ��uU�uu�U SIDE VIEW ILLUMINATION VIEW FOUR SETS REVERSE PAN CHANNEL LETTERS ALUMINUM FACES & 2" ALUMINUM RETURNS POWDER COATED WHITE CLEAR POLYCARBONATE BACKS WHITE L.E.D. HALO ILLUMINATION INSTALLED ON BUILDING WITH 1 1/2" STAND OFFS ONE EA. INSTALLED ON EAST ELEVATION ONE EA. INSTALLED ON WEST ELEVATION 11'-10" L 3'-1" _i 4'-0" 88.5 SQ. FT. SIDE VIEWS DIF ILLUMINATED MONUMENT SIGN A -ALUMINUM TENANT CABINETS PAINTED PEPPERCORN (SW 7674) INTERNAL L.E.D. ILLUMINATION 314' CLEAR ACRYLIC PUSH THROUGH GRAPHICS WITH SECOND SURFACE DIFFUSER 8 FIRST SURFACE OPAQUE VINYL B-ALUMINUM TOP CAP AND REVEALS PAINTED SATIN BLACK C - NICHIHA CORBOSA CONCRETE SERIES WALL PANELS (SHADOW) .125 ALUMINUM ADDRESS POWDER COATED WHITE FLUSHMOUNTED D-VERTICAL ACCENT WITH LONGBOARD SIDING CLADDING (COLOR TBD) E - INTERSTATE BRICK: EMPEROR MIDNIGHT BLACK COLOR IN STACKED PATTERN INSTALLED WITH STEEL POLE IN CONCRETE FOOTING ILLUMINATION VIEW Ll MULTI -TENANT OFFICE (MEDICAL/DENTAL AND BUSINESS/PROFESSIONAL) BUILDING OGLE, I�p'� DR-33-23 Eagle Design Review Board Meeting July 13, 2023 City Staff: Barbara A. Williams, Planner II Phone: 939-0227 ....:. E-Mail: Vicinity Map ,4 Landscape Plan East and West Building Elevations North and South Building Elevations South Roof Plan North Revised 40 Perspectives . I g iilr� Issues of Special Concern • Architecture deferred to the Board • Trash enclosure pedestrian access • Cross section of the roof top mechanical units Issues of Special Concern • Trash enclosure pedestrian access • Cross section of the roof top mechanical units Building Architecture m r�� 7/25/2023 �°�Uf(iflill (�c=ilull r_ o��, `iiri�lrL�oi �itol iinli�` I�Xj.ejl"r;of 0 _5 c tikoini oii iilni( ro;Ko "fd bi Inpl_Yc.11n)(Ncal�� iUjln)IhS` 11 12 Issues of Special Concern • Architecture deferred to the Board • Trash enclosure pedestrian access Cross section of roof top units — SSC#3 Issues of Special Concern • Architecture deferred to the Board • Trash enclosure pedestrian access — SSC#2 • Cross section of the roof top mechanical units — SSC#3 End of Presentation