Minutes - 2013 - Eagle Public Library - 11/18/2013 - Regular
EAGLE PUBLIC LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES
MINUTES
November 18, 2013
Community Room
Board President Maureen Germano called the Eagle Public Library Board of Trustees meeting to order at
7:04 pm. Present were Board Members Pete Dover, Christine Lodge, Terri Soelberg and Margo Walter
(who arrived at 7:11). Also present were Library Director Steve Bumgarner and Assistant Library
Director Janice Campbell.
Approval of Agenda for November 18, 2013, Board of Trustees Meeting
Library Director Bumgarner requested that the agenda be amended as follows:
Sunday Hours be added after 3M sales agreement
Coats for Kids be added after Sunday hours
And Fiftieth Anniversary be added after Vocational training
New Business
Oath of Office be added above Public Use of Library Telephone Policy
Board of Trustees Directory be added after Goals and Objectives
Pete Dover made the motion to approve the agenda with amendments; seconded by Terri Soelberg, the
agenda was unanimously approved.
Approval of Minutes of October 7, 2013, Board of Trustees Meeting
Walter made the motion to approve the minutes for the Septe
holiday closure of City
made the motion
to approve the minutes for the October 7, 2013 meeting as amended; seconded by Pete Dover, the
minutes were unanimously approved.
Payment of Library Bills
Christine Lodge made the motion to approve the bills for payment; seconded by Pete Dover, the bills
were unanimously approved for payment.
Due to the absence of a Friends representative, no report was given. Library Director Steve Bumgarner
reported that the book sale held on October 18 and October 19 netted the Friends approximately
$1,700. The Friends work with Book Scouter continues to be productive.
Direc
Circulation statistics reflect a busier October over the same month one year ago. October 2013 saw a
fifteen percent increase in usage of library materials over the same period in 2012. October statistics
highlights include:
12% increases in
average daily circulation for the month of October at 1,096 compared to 953 a year ago),
50% increase in ebook circulation,
21% increase in patron traffic, and
Programming attendance up by 69%.
Eagle patrons downloaded 450 songs from Freegal.
Library publicity materials for the month of October were distributed. In October, the Library was
mentioned in:
The Independent (program listings for the month).
Along with all LYNX! Consortium libraries, Eagle received a Public Records Request from channel KIVI for
all records from January 2012 to present in which patrons complained about books that appeared on
any and all records pertaining to any patron complaint or challenge of any item during the same period.
The City Attorney advised the Library to submit all records of the only complaint it received (about Kelly
ŷĻ ƚƒğƓ ŷƚ IĻğƩķ /ƚƌƚƩ). The patron comp
child may or may not checkout (not a library or a library staff member).
The Library received, from the Idaho Commission for Libraries, the 2013 Library Law Manual. Board
members were asked who would like printed copies; the Library will print copies as appropriate.
On October 24, 2013, the Eagle Public Library hosted the second annual Horizon Users Group
conference at the Library and City Hall. Over eighty LYNX! Consortium library staff members attended as
did four representatives from Sirsi/Dynix (the supplier of t
filled with numerous presentations and meetings all of which attendees found very informative. Eagle
(the City and the Library) looked very good and staff heard positive comment after positive comment
about the day.
The sales agreement between the City and 3M is approved by the City Attorney and is ready for
signature. As the agreement is between the City and 3M (not the Library and 3M), the agreement will
be sent to City Hall to be placed on the consent agenda for the next City Council meeting (November
26). The after approval, the document will be signed by the Mayor and returned to 3M.
The Meridian Library District will begin offering Sunday hours in January 2014.
The Eagle Public Library is assisting the Eagle Chamber of Commerce as a collection point for coats for
kids.
During the past month, the Eagle Public Library worked with two occupational training programs. In
both cases, the sponsoring organization sends an assigned trainer with the participant. The trainer stays
with the participant the entire time, monitoring how well the participant works, follows directions, and
gets along with their co-workers. In each case, very little staff time is involved.
Finally, the Library will conclude its fiftieth year of service to the community with a special day-long
event on Monday, December 9. From 9:00 am to about 11:00 am, and then from 3:00 pm to about 6:00
pm, the Library is inviting the community to stop by, listen to music, have a cookie or two and some
coffee or punch, and share their library memories. Staff are working to create various ways to capture
some the library memories which will then be made available to the public. A harpist and pianist will be
here to provide music and staff will be stationed in the building to welcome guests. Then, as a special
treat, at 11:30 am, the Eagle Elementary Honor Choir will be at the Library to perform.
Library Liaison / City Hall Reports (City Councilman Mark Butler)
Due to the absence of City Councilman Butler, no report was given.
New Business
Trustee Oath of Office
Office. No instructions were included with the form and existing Board members do not recall signing
the form. After discussion, it was decided that the form was not necessary.
Public Use of Library Telephone Policy
With the remodel of the Circulation Desk complete, and taking into account the change in both staff and
patron use of the space, the telephone intended for patron use was removed. Over time, the phone
became the personal phone of a few patrons they would spend far longer than the requested two-
minute limit on the phone as they made a variety of personal business calls. At times, allowing patrons
to place personal calls at a public service desk was disruptive to being able to provide other patrons with
the customer service they needed to resolve library-related business. Patrons who need to place a call
to ask for a ri
the phone is to call for a ride and to keep the call limited to that. The staff is reminded to be flexible and
to work with the patron as necessary, keeping in mind the proposed policy. Upon discussion of the
proposed policy, the Board was asked to approve the Public Use of Library Telephone Policy.
Pete Dover made the motion to approve the Public Use of Library Telephone Policy; seconded by Margo
Walter, the Public Use of Library Telephone Policy was unanimously approved.
Video Game Collection Amendment to the Collection Development Policy
This was a frequently requested addition to the Library by its patrons, so to satisfy patron demand the
Library began acquiring video games late in October. Staff members Megan Williamson (with assistance
from David Hergenrather) purchased an initial collection of items. Through Sunday, November 17, 2013,
seventy-five games) had a circulation of sixty-two
(checked-out at Eagle; additional circulation occurred when the items were transferred for circulation to
other libraries) for
games; as such, at the request of the Library Director, Megan Williamson wrote a video game collection
policy which the Library will incorporate into the Collection Development Policy. The proposed policy
A brief discussion
ensued about the evolution and future of DVDs and that as more companies begin to offer streaming
and downloadble feature films to library patrons, DVD circulation will probably decline (likewise, as
more game developers offer cloud-based gaming, circulation of game discs will likely decline). Upon
discussion of the proposed video game collection amendment to the Collection Development Policy, the
Board was asked to approve proposed amendment (with the above noted changes). Terri Soelberg
made the motion to amend the Collection Development Policy with the addition of the Video Game
Amendment to the Collection Development Policy; seconded by Christine Lodge, the amendment to the
Collection Development Policy was unanimously approved.
Food for Fines
Food for fines during July of 2013 was a huge success, generating so much interest that the Food Bank
made pickups at the Library daily. The average monthly collection in fines is $2,069. During July 2013,
the amount collected was $1,675 \[in 2012, July collection was just over $1,900\]. While the amount of
the fine collection dropped slightly, both organizations benefitted: the Food Bank with extra donations
and the Library with many cards cleared. Other libraries are planning to participate with their local food
banks; Meridian allows food for fines all year \[often while helping patrons who have fines, the Eagle
by not
offering food for fines all year, the Library potentially loses a patron so they can conduct part (if not all)
of their future business at another library; Eagle should consider Food for Fines throughout the year\].
The Library is proposing to work again with the Eagle Community Food Bank this December and offer
Food for Fines yet again, with the same limitations as this summer; the Board countered by offering to
make Food for Fines a year-round program, with increased promotion during the summer and winter
holiday periods. Upon discussion of the Food for Fines, the Board was asked to approve its proposal.
Pete Dover made the motion to approve accepting food (or other non-perishables) for fines on a year-
round basis with twice a-year promotion (for a maximum $50.00 waive), with all donations being
collected for the Eagle Community Food Bank.; seconded by Christine Lodge, the authorization to
conduct Food for Fines as outlined above was approved unanimously.
Surplus List
With the installation of the new checkout system, and while continuing to streamline and open access to
all of the collection, the Library generated list of items to be surplused. Upon discussion of the items on
the list, the Board was asked to approve the list. Terri Soelberg made the motion to recommend to City
Council that all items listed on the surplus list be approved for surplus; seconded by Pete Dover, the
recommend to City Council that all items listed on the surplus list be approved for surplus was approved
unanimously.
Job Descriptions
At the request of the Board, Library Director presented updated job descriptions for all staff. All job
descriptions should be submitted to the City Attorney before final adoption. President Maureen
Germano suggested that the Board review the job descriptions prior to next Board meeting and bring
their recommendations to the December meeting. Library Director Bumgarner reminded the Board that
all job descriptions would then need to be reviewed by the City Attorney.
Goals and Objectives
At the request of the Board, the Goals and Objectives for Fiscal Year 2013-2014 were distributed by
Library Director Bumgarner. The goals and objectives were developed in conjunction with, and
monthly throughout the year to update progress on all goals and objectives.
Board of Trustees directory
The Eagle Public Library Board of Trustees FY 2013/2014 directory was distributed by Library Director
Bumgarner. The Library Director asked the Board to check their individual entries and, if updates or
corrections are needed, to so indicate on the sheet and return it to the Library Director. Corrections will
be made and the directory redistributed to all Board members at the December meeting.
Board of Trustees meeting dates for 2014
The preliminary The Eagle Public Library Board of Trustees Meeting Dates for 2014 was distributed by
Library Director Bumgarner. The Library Director asked to Board to review the dates and approve the
document (changing one incorrect reference from 2013 to 2014) so that the dates may be publicly
published as required by Idaho Code.
Pete Dover made the motion to accept the submitted dates for the 2014 Eagle Public Library Board of
Trustees meetings; seconded by Terri Soelberg, the amended dates for the 2014 Eagle Public Library
Board of Trustees meetings was approved unanimously.
Additional Items or Public Comment
President Maureen Germano suggested that new Board members (Christine Lodge and Terri Soelberg)
be given a tour of the Library and meet staff. After brief discussion, it was decided that Board Members
Lodge and Soelberg will attend the December 19 staff meeting, at which time they will meet staff
members and then be given a tour of the facility).
There were no additional items or public comment.
Selection of Next Meeting Date
The next regularly scheduled meeting is Monday, December 9, 2013, at 7:00 pm in the Eagle Public
Adjournment
There being no further business, President Germano adjourned the meeting at 8:33 pm.
Respectfully submitted,
Janice Campbell
Assistant Library Director