Minutes - 2016 - Historic Preservation Commission - 03/09/2016 - SpecialTHE CITY OF EAGLE
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMI33ION
Special Meeting Minutes
Eagle City Hall, 660 E. Civic Lane
March 9, 2016 5:30 P.M.
1. CALL TO ORDER: calls the meeting to order at p.m.
2. ROLL CALL: Present: NICKEL, CULTON, DAVINA Absent: STAFFORD, PENCE.
3. UNFINISHED BUSINESS:
Chairman Culton states that the Beggrow's and Murrison's have reached out to the Commission to
discuss preserving their property and any resources that may be available. The Beggrow Family called
today and had an unexpected conflict arise and thus are unable to be here tonight.
A. NRHP Nomination and Historic Properties Q &A
1. Beggrows' Property ( "Dicky Dr" Barn) — see above.
2. Murrisons' Property (Johnson- Draper Farmstead) 2380 W. Beacon Light Road
Rich Murrison, he and his wife Teri Murrison own the property. They have been restoring the home, but
the barn has not been addressed yet. Shingles continue to fall during storms and you can see daylight
from the interior. He is uncertain when the actual barn was constructed. Discussion.
Chairman Culton notes that according to the windshield survey that was conducted last year, the barn is
eligible for designation. The property is actually outside of Eagle City limits, but it is our hope to
preserve these local barns. The Commission is definitely interested in the process and perhaps there
would be tax credits available.
Museum Coordinator states that perhaps Ada County would be a swifter route to designate it on the
register. The Commission states they will help.
At the last meeting the Commission decided to pursue the nomination of the Beggrow Property, but it
may have to wait until next fiscal year.
B. Grants, Signs, and Plaques
Culton provides a report. He requests staff research exact costs for the signage to assist him in preparing
a grant.
Council Liaison Soelberg notes that there is a group called Beautify Downtown Eagle that is working on
signage, branding and other things. This may be a great group for the Commission to work with and
perhaps participate in. He will forward that information to Chairman Culton.
C. Subcommittee updates
1. Quarterly Speaker's Program —Chief Calley Presentation in May
Nickel gives a brief review of the program. This May they are working with Police Chief Calley, and he
will be doing a presentation on World War II. He will be re- enacting memories that a neighbor of his that
he was gracious enough to share. The dates will be either May 25`h or 26`h at the Library. This will be a
great tie in for the Field of Honor. Nickel will work with City staff to advertise the event, as well as
reaching out to the Senior Center, local schools and other outlets.
Museum Curator Dunn states that per the request of Commission she has submitted Eagle's History walk
to the State Historic Preservation Commission (SHPO) to get on their History Month Celebration
calendar of event.
2. Pioneer Cemetery: No report
Page I of 2
D. Museum Curator's Report & CLG Questionnaire: Dunn will work with the Commission and staff to
distribute the History Month posters throughout the City. She continues to work on the Eagle Island
Prison Farm display for the museum. Dunn reviews a portion of the CLG Questionnaire with the
Commission.
E. Preservation Month — Walking Tour Brochures: Discussed earlier.
F. Historic District: No report.
4. NEW BUSINESS:
A. Minutes of February 10, 2016
Nickel moves to approve minutes of February 10, 2016. Seconded by Davina. ALL
AYE ... MOTION CARRIES.
B. Welcome New Commissioners!
Chairman welcomes Commissioner Davina.
C. Municipal Registry Evaluation & Historic Properties Task Force
Chairman Culton states that he has been requested to seek an alternate person to assist with the evaluation
of the municipal registry. Commissioner Davina agrees to provide assistance.
Dunn provides an update. According to the City Clerk/Treasurer, Commissioner Culton has been
appointed Vice - Chairman of the Task Force with Ms. Dunn as the Chairman. This group will be reaching
out to the property owners of all of those property owners of those properties on the municipal registry. A
script and some training will be done for all of the Task Force Members so when they go out and contact
the property owners, consistent and accurate information will be provided to each of the property owners.
1. Updates
2. Planning and Scope
D. Comprehensive Plan Committee Update: No report.
E. General Discussion of Upcoming projects, events
Budget discussion for fiscal year 2016 -2017 will be added to next month's agenda.
5. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, moved to adjourn 6:45 p.m..
Nickel moves to adjourn. Seconded by Stafford. ALL AYES: MOTION
CARRIED ...............................
Respectfully submitted:
HAR ON K. BERG MANN
CITY CLERK/TREASURER
APPROVE s:
MIKE CULTON
Cy re IT1:7TG1,1
AN AUDIO RECORDING OF THIS MEETING IS AVAILABLE FOR DOWNLOAD AT
WWW.CITYOFEAGLE.ORG
Page 2 of 2
POSSIBLE "EAGLE REGISTER OF HISTORIC SITES" SITES
The properties highlighted in pale brown are those Eagle properties currently listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Those higlI)ighted in yellow are potential National
Register nominees. These will undoubtedly be automatically included on the Eagle Register of Historic Sites. The rest need to be photographed, their architectural style
identified, and title searched at the Ada County Assessor's Office.
Field k# Property Name
Address
Circa 1998 1999 2006 Ada Co. No's in Date
Date Ada Co. Ada Co. Eagle Hist Site Picture Picture(s)
Survey Survey Survey Inventory Range Taken
X
106 New Height Baptist Youth 91 N 1st St 1920
Center
105 Carpenter/McAdams House 120 N 1st St 1905 X X
120 2nd St house 1148 2nd St 1905 X
119 ,S2nd Sthouse '205S2nd St 1930 X
101 Thomas Aikens House 78 E Aikens 1905 X
102 Blue Moose Cafe 79 E Aikens 1925 X
098 Aikens Rd house 97 W Aikens Rd 1935 X
007 S Artesian Rd farmstead 1624 S Artesian Rd 1909 X
013 N Ballantyne Lane farmstead 843 N Ballantyne Lane 1931 X
Eagle Adventist Schoolhouse 1155 N Ballantyne Ln 1912
014 IN Ballantyne Lane house 11571 N Ballantyne Lane 1920 X
Farmers Union Canal headgate Beacon Light Road
072 Beacon Light Rd house W Beacon Light Rd 1925 X
024 E Beacon Light Rd house 232 E Beacon Light Rd 1900 X
023 E Beacon Light Rd house 278 E Beacon Light Rd 1900 X
022 W Beacon Light Rd farmstead 2141 W Beacon Light Rd 1905 X
021 W Beacon Light Rd farmstead 2380 W Beacon Light Rd 1905 X
074 Beacon Light Rd house 3632 W Beacon Light Rd 1930 X
073 Beacon Light Rd house 4130 W Beacon Light Rd 1930 X X
190 Eagle Road Chicken Coop 4037 Eagle Rd 1920 X
110 N Eagle Rd house 323 N Eagle Rd 1940 X
115 Eagle High & Grammar School 475 N Eagle Rd 1913 X
Storage and Gym Building
012 IN Eagle Rd house 1691 N Eagle Rd 1910 X
i
pg 89
pg 88
Field # 1 Property Name Address
Raymond Hamming farmstead
099 Rembrandt's Coffee House
Day and Blake House
100 Orville & Floy Jackson House
025 W Floating Feather Rd
farmstead
026 W Floating Feather Rd house
027 W Floating Feather farmstead
028 W Floating Feather farmstead
029 W Floating Feather Rd house
030 W Floating Feather Rd house
005 W Hatchery Rd house
107 E Idaho St house
108 E Idaho St house
109 E Idaho St house
163 Joplin Road Dairy barn
071 ,Slaughterhouse
019 N Linder Rd farmstead
143 & Ron Sali Farmstead
144
121 Eagle Island Honor Farm
Barn #1
122 Eagle Island Honor Farm
Administrative Bldg
123 Eagle Island Honor Farm
Barn #2
124 Eagle Island Honor Farm
Barn #3
i
5635 Eagle Rd
93 S Eagle Rd
174 S Eagle Rd
127 S Eagle Rd
70 W Floating Feather Rd
235 W Floating Feather Rd
524 W Floating Feather Rd
2500 W Floating Feather Rd
3100 W Floating Feather Rd
3395 W Floating Feather Rd
4660 Hatchery Rd
197 E Idaho St
154 E Idaho St
226 E Idaho St
W Joplin Rd (adjacent to
Orme Hereford Ranch)
410 N Linder Rd
4520 N Linder Rd
919 S Linder (Three Rivers
Ranch Rd)
2691 Mace Rd
2691 Mace Rd
2691 Mace Rd
12691 Mace Rd
Circa 1998
Date Ada Co.
Survey
1890 X
1932 X
1900
1915
1900
1900
1905
1910
1920
1940
1910
1915
1915
1930 X
1912
1900
1940
1940
1940
1932
1999
Ada Co.
Survey
2006
Eagle
Survey
X
Ada Co.
Hist Site
Inventory
pg 87
pg 87
pg 91
pg 91
pg 91
pg 91
No's in
Picture
Range
Date
Picture(s)
Taken
Field #
125
Property Name
Eagle Island Honor Farm
Superintendent's Res
126 Eagle Island Honor Farm
Slaughterhouse
063 Villeneuve House
079 101d Valley Rd house
078 _1,OId Valley Rd house
008 Old Valley Road Nursery
004 IS Palmer Lane house
112 Park house
076 ,N Park Lane house
077 N Park Lane house
017 N Park Lane house
016 IN Park Lane farmstead
015 N Park Lane farmstead
097 5 Park Road house
111 5 Park Road house
113 IS Park Road house
114 IS Park Road house
002 N Sierra View Way house
117 Eagle Hotel
104 Seam Etc
103 DaVinci's Restaurant
082 (Country Pub
096 State St house (Hwy 44)
116 !Eagle Paint & Glass (Gas
Station)
095 State St house (Hwy 44)
094 State St house (Hwy 44)
Address
2691 Mace Rd
2691 Mace Rd
7575 W Moon Valley Rd
4001 W Old Valley Rd
14278 W Old Valley Rd
4557 W Old Valley Rd
209 5 Palmer Lane
317 Park Lane
'183 N Park Lane
;1012 N Park Lane
2257 N Park Lane
4567 N Park Lane
4600 N Park Lane
187 S Park Rd
265 S Park
288 S Park
378 S Park
132 N Sierra View Way
99 E State St
'124 E State St
190E State St
W State St (Hwy 44)
119 W State St
1272 W State St
349 W State St
386 W State St
Circa 1998 1999 2006
I Date Ada Co. Ada Co__ Eagle
Survey Survey Survey
X
1935
1965
1881
1910
1930
1900 _
1900
X
X
X
1940
1940 X
1940 X
1892
1920
1910
11910 X
1930
1905
1910
1910 •
r —
1940 X
1925 X
1940
1900
1915
X
X
X
X
X
X X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Ada Co.
Hist Site
Inventory
pg 91
pg 91
pg 90
pg 90
pg 89 '
pg 88
pg 86
No's in
Picture
Range
I --
Date
Picture(s)
Taken
Field #
_
093
092
091
Property Name
O.F. Short House
State St house (Hwy 44)
State St house (Hwy 44)
09011208 W State St
089
088
127
086
085
084
003
083
081
080
006
001
State St house (Hwy 44)
State St house (Hwy 44)
State St house (Hwy 44)
State St barn
State St house (Hwy 44)
State St house (Hwy 44)
State St house (Hwy 44)
W State St house
State St house (Hwy 44)
|StateSt house (Hwy 44)
State St house (Hwy 44)
STrout Rd farmstead
S Waterton Ave farmsted
Address
550 W State St
825 W State St
63 W State St
!1209 W State St
Circa 1998 | 1999 i 2006 Ada[o� No's Date
^
Date : Ada Co. / Ada Co. Eagle Hist Site Picture Picture(s)
Survey | Survey Survey
1906 X
1910 | X
19]O! X
1925 X
1910 X
1389 W State St 1935 X
1770 W State St 1910�
2500 W State St 1930X
2501 W State St 1935 X
� —
27SSVVState 5t 1920 X
|Z8l0VVState St 1930
2811 W State St 1935 X
3205 W State St 1925 X
3950 W State St 1900 X
2077 S Trout Rd 1940
1033 S Waterton Ave
1949
-----T' --
i � |
1-
X
X
X
X
X
X
Inventory Range Taken
pg 86
L
014164
I'I- al8lik
INVENTORIED PROPERTIES SHEET
CITY OF EAGLE CLG BARN WINDSHIELD SURVEY
Madeline Buckendorf Consulting, LLC, SUMMER 2015
[Note: E15=Eagle 2015; IHSI No. = SHPO number previously assigned to property.
Ada Co. HRP MPS=Ada County Rural Historic Properties Multiple Property Study, 2001]
Temp. Field IHSI No. * Name Location
No.
E15-01 01-19050 Mossman Barn
E15-02 01-23202 Muller Farmstead
E15-03
E15-04
E15-05
E15-06
E15-07
,owN E15-08
E15-09
E15-10
E15-11
E15-12
E15-13
E15-14
E15-15
El 5-16
E15-17
E15-18
E15-19
01-23259
01-23258
01-21835
01-21830
N. Palmer Lane
Property -621
N. Palmer Lane
Dairy -401
Fry Farmstead -
Barn
N. Ballentyne
Lane Barn- 843
N. Ballentyne
Lane Bam-842
Mosier Property
N. Eagle Road
Farmstead -2511
N. Eagle Road
Barn -2022
N. Park Lane
Farmstead -4770
N. Park Lane
Farmstead -4567
"Green Acres"
Farmstead
Los Luceros
Drive Barn -1098
River Heights
Drive Bam-795
01-21826 S. Artesian Rd.
Farmstead -1624
01-21826 S. Trout Rd.
Farmstead -2077
01-19715 W. State Street
Bam-1770
E15-20 01-19055
E15-21
01-23165?
W. State Street
Bam-1601
W. State Street
Bam-6211
Highway 44
Barn -6210
570 Highway #16
City Limits or
Vicinity
(Area of Impact)
Eligible/Criterion
or Not Eligible or
Local Historic
Interest
✓ Eligible
320 N. Palmer Lane V Barns may be
Eligible —Ada Co.
HRP MPS
621 N. Palmer Lane V Not Eligible
401 N. Palmer Lane V Not Eligible
4520 N. Linder Road V Bam Eligible -Ada
Co. HRP MPS
843 N. Ballentyne C Barn Individually
Lane Eligible
842 N. Ballentyne C Barn Eligible -Ada
Lane Co. HRP MPS
3704 N. Ballentyne C Not Eligible
Lane
2511 N. Eagle Rd. C Barnyard Eligible -
Ada. Co. HRP MPS
2022 N. Eagle Rd. C E? Needs
Intensive -level
survey
4770 N. Park Lane V Not Eligible
4567 N. Park Lane V Not Eligible
2686 N. Park Lane V Bams Eligible -Ada
1098 Los Luceros
Drive
795 River Heights
Drive
1624 S. Artesian
Road
2077 S. Trout Rd.
1770 W. State St.
1601 W. State St.
6211 W. State St.
6210 W. State St.
Co. HRP MPS
C E? Need Intensive -
level survey
✓ Not Eligible
✓ Bamyard Eligible?
Need Intensive -
level survey
✓ Barn Eligible?
Need Intensive -
level survey
C Bam Eligible?
Need Intensive -
level survey
C Not Eligible
C Not Eligible?
Further info needed
C Determined Not
Eligible in 2013 -
Barn may be
individually Eligible
Temp. Field !HSI No. Name Location
No.
E15-22
E15-23
E15-24
E15-25
E15-26
E15-27
E15-28
E15-29
E15-30
E15-31
E15-32
E15-33
E15-34
E15-35
E15-36
E15-37
E15-38
E15-39
E15-40
01-15326 Jones Property
01-19068 Chaney Property
01-19064 Lilac Lane Barns -
4011
01-21828
01-15323
01-21843
01-21842
01-21840
01-21837
01-21836
01-15320
01-15321
01-1562
01-23096
01-21832
Old Valley Road
Nursery -4557
Moon Valley Rd.
Barn -6615
W. Floating
Feather Rd.
Farmstead -2500
W. Floating
Feather Rd.
Farmstead -524
W. Floating
Feather Rd.
Farmstead -70
W. Beacon Light
Rd. Farmstead -
2141
W. Beacon Light
Rd. Farmstead -
2380
W. Beacon Light
Rd. Barn -263?
W. Beacon Light
Rd. Barn -6166
N. Linder Rd.
Farmstead -3251
[orig. George W.
Fry Barn]
Brookside Lane
Farmstead -4401
Highway #55
Barn -13103
Dicky Drive Barn -
325
N. Park Lane
Farmstead -4600
Carlson Barn
W. Mace Road
Property -800
58 N. Truman Drive
2755 Highway #44
4011 Lilac Lane
4557 Old Valley Rd.
6615 Moon Valley
Road
2500 W. Floating
Feather Road
524 W. Floating
Feather Road
70 W. Floating
Feather Road
2141 W. Beacon
Light Road
2380 W. Beacon
Light Road
263? W. Beacon
Light Road
6166 W. Beacon
Light Road
3251 N. Linder Road
4401 Brookside
Lane
13103 Highway #55
325 Dicky Drive
4600 N. Park Lane
2033 W. Mace Road
800 W. Mace Road
City Limits or
Vicinity
(Area of Impact)
C
C
C
Eligible/Criterion
or Not Eligible or
Local Historic
Interest
Eligible-Bam only?
Eligible? Check
against 2013 site
form
Property
determined Not
Eligible in 2013—
Barns may be
Eligible under Ada
Co. RHP MPS
Not Eligible
Barn Eligible?
Needs intensive -
level survey
Milking shed,
granary Eligible
under Ada Co.
RHP -MPS?
Barn & Silo Eligible
under Ada Co.
RHP -MPS
Not Eligible
Not Eligible
Barn Eligible
Not Eligible?
Local historical
interest
Not Eligible
Not Eligible
Not Eligible
Not Eligible
Eligible
Not Eligible
Not Eligible
Not Eligible -but of
local historical
interest