Loading...
Minutes - 2006 - Design Review - 08/10/2006 - Regular DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MINUTES The Design Review Board met in regular session August 10, 2006, Chairman McCullough presiding. I. CALL TO ORDER: Chairman McCullough calls the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m. 2. ROLL CALL: The following members were present: MC CULLOUGH, GRUBB, BARNES, MACDONALD, COUNCIL LIAISON BASTIAN. A quorum is present. ABSENT: STANGER, WEBER, WRIGHT. 3. CONSENT AGENDA . Consent Agenda items are considered to be routine and are acted on with one motion. There will be no separate discussion on these items unless a Design Review Board member, City Staff, or a citizen requests an item to be removed from the Consent Agenda for discussion. Items removed from the Consent Agenda will be placed on the Regular Agenda in a sequence determined by the Rules of Order. . Any item on the Consent Agenda that contains written recommendations from the City of Eagle shall be adopted as part of the Design Review's Consent Agenda approval motion unless specifically stated otherwise. A. Minutes of July 27, 2006. B. Findine:s of Fact and Conclusions of Law for DR-56-06 - Master Sie:n Plan for St. Luke's Ree:ional Medical Center - St. Luke's Ree:ional Medical Center: St. Luke's Regional Medical Center, represented by Thomas Zabala, AlA, with ZGA Architects and Planners, is requesting design review approval of a master sign plan for the St. Luke's Regional Medical Center. The site is located on the southwest comer of East State Street and Horseshoe Bend Road at 310 I East State Street. C. Findine:s of Fact and Conclusions of Law for DR-64-06 - Common Area Landscapine: and Sports Academy Facility within Lee:acy PUD - Sie:nature Sports Development: Signature Sports Development, represented by Jeremy Ainsworth with The Land Group, is requesting design review approval of the common area landscaping and a 32,070-square foot sports academy facility within Legacy PUD. The 228-acre site is generally located near the southwest comer of Floating Feather Road and Linder Road. Barnes moves to place items 5D and 5E on the consent agenda. Seconded by Grubb. ALL A YE...MOTION CARRIES. Barnes moves to accept the consent agenda as items 3A, 3B, 3C along with the addition of items 5D and 5E. Seconded by Grubb. ALL AYE. ..MOTION CARRIES. Page I of 4 K:IDESI_REVIMINUTESITemporary Minutes Work AreaIDR-08-IQ-06min.doc 4. UNFINISHED BUSINESS: A. DR-52-06 - Monument Sie:n for Great Sky Office Park - Gloria Keulman: Gloria Keulman, represented by Sydney Holgreen with Idaho Electric Signs, is requesting design review approval to construct a monument sign for Great Sky Office Park. The site is located at the southwest comer of Hill Road and South Wooddale Avenue at 219-231 South Wooddale Avenue. This item was continued/rom the July 27,2006 meeting. Grubb moves to continue DR-52-06 - Monument Sign for Great Sky Office Park to the next regularly scheduled meeting. Seconded by Barnes. ALL A YE...MOTION CARRIES. 5. NEW BUSINESS: A. DR-72-06 - Master Sie:n Plan for Bosanka Villae:e - Mark Guho: Mark Guho, represented by Roger Huber with Young Electric Signs, LLC, is requesting design review approval of a master sign plan for Bosanka Village. The site is located on the south side of West State Street approximately 230-feet west of Harlan Lane at 391 West State Street. Rober Huber, 5511 W. Lockwood Drive reviews the application. Staff member Verschuren reviews the application. Board discussion. Further discussion with the applicant. Grubb moves to approve DR-72-06 - Master Sign Plan for Bosanka Village with the site specific and standard conditions of approval with the following modifications to the site specific conditions of approval: Site specific condition # C6: All letters shall be painted earth tone colors and white neon or LED shall be used to illuminate the sign age. Seconded by Barnes. ALL A YE...MOTION CARRIES. B. DR-75-06 - Multi-Tenant Medical Office and Professional Office Buildine:- Cobblestone Properties. LLC: Cobblestone Properties, LLC, represented by Russ Philips with Insight Architects, is requesting design review approval of a 32,744- square foot multi-tenant medical office and professional office building. The 2.2-acre site is located on the northwest corner of North Story Book Way and West State Street at 450 West State Street. Joe Bruce, with Insight Architects in Boise reviews the application. Staff member Verschuren reviews the application. Board discussion. McCullough moves to approve DR-75-06 - Multi-Tenant Medical Office and Professional Office Building with the site specific and standard conditions of approval as written within the staff report. Seconded by Grubb. ALL AYE...MOTION CARRIES. C. DR-76-06 - Master Silm Plan for a Multi-tenant Medical Office and Professional Office Buildine: - Cobblestone Properties. LLC: Cobblestone Properties, LLC, represented by Russ Philips with Insight Architects, is requesting design review approval of a master sign plan for a multi-tenant medical office and professional Page 2 of 4 K:\DESI_REVIMINUTESITemporary Minutes Work AreaIDR-08-IQ-06min.doc office building. The 2.2-acre site is located on the northwest comer of North Story Book Way and West State Street at 450 West State Street. Joe Bruce, reviews the application. Staff member Verschuren reviews the application. Board discussion. McCullough moves to continue DR-76-06 - Master Sign Plan for a Multi-tenant Medical Office and Professional Office Building to the next meeting with the direction offered by staff and the Design Review Board. Seconded by Grubb. ALL A YE...MOTION CARRIES. D. DR-77-06 - Common Area Landscapine: within Kathleen Estates - Capital Development & Tom Ricks: Capital Development and Tom Ricks, represented by David Koga with The Land Group, Inc, are requesting design review approval of the common area landscaping within Kathleen Estates. The site is located on the west side of North Park Lane approximately 1 ,320-feet north of West State Street at 325 North Park Lane. This item was moved to the consent agenda. E. DR-78-06 - Monument Sie:n for Kathleen Estates - Capital Development & Tom Ricks: Capital Development and Tom Ricks, represented by David Koga with The Land Group, Inc, are requesting design review approval to construct one monument sign for Kathleen Estates. The site is located on the west side of North Park Lane approximately 1 ,320-feet north of West State Street at 325 North Park Lane. This item was moved to the consent agenda. 6. REPORTS: A. Design Review Board: No Report. B. Council Liaison: No Report. C. Staff: No Report. 7. ADJOURNMENT: Barnes moves to adjourn at 7:10 p.m. Seconded by Grubb. ALL A YE...MOTION CARRIES. RESPECTFULL Y SUBMITTED: ............ ,., -.. ........ Of EAO ..... ~ .co{ ......... (,i-, '. ~ .'" . .. ~- e. ~ ,.~... dyORAl';.. '. :: ...,1.... v. ~ : . ~~ . .. : . . ~ .~ . !.. I ..... ~: :: \ \:-..."SBA~~'1o i '- tS',.~:J.'t....~~ l -,~ 1'e Of \~....'" "............. 1l(~CL--V- 0-b~~ ./ SHARON K. BERGMANN CITY CLERK/TREASURER Page 3 of 4 K:\DESI_REVIMINUTESITemporary Minutes Work Area\DR-08-IQ-06min.doc ERIC R. MCCULLOUGH CHAIRMAN A TRANSCRIBABLE RECORD OF THIS MEETING IS AVAILABLE AT CITY HALL. Page 4 of 4 K:\DESI_ REVIMINUTESITemporary Minutes Work AreaIDR-08-1 0-06min.doc y 47RE RI \'may P/12.. 1::,...,.....,..,;:.:,;%:1,;:,....rbgrrgtg; I.,''.k*N`., g.--io—0 (e ,„,...„.,,,.,„,..._,.. „‘„,,..,„,,...„,„., 4,/ 't:P '1'DOIYi •'Gi'UDI ' r< ,i .4 'j -a August 10 2006 ;� '_..... {� + ',�;fit_��.+,k•?:. ��t�.iy.'w�t*tea:�`.F • � .�>. t ,- -.,, City of Eagle .�� � � ,.,c.�..,4.:, �� TO: Barb @ ty -,r>;R.T • z � ri:a" :;� :Lieu t:r;5-aStudio ' -;�,,;y t4 ir '=`• a , " FROM: No B. r t@ Classic Design : r . .;.1'. ;.�' :,;t. ':; "; :.�As:.•!:a ,.;:;,f•.�:r�.4::r;::, li RE: Design Review Board - "= ., -!.: Barb, "z.v, *4--1,:,,-.,' � proposed k,,tI ,w.eti. wino are the comments on signage propo �:wr"tlwilw;?(w'`�'< :a �{.'.T!'•��i:,,f,!sn.:M-a,;� ��ll� b f a t z"""�`r.c!,,5:. a �w i.` for Eaole Design Review. . °<<k ;,;,.: „� -,A ':.y1;0� h' 1. #5A File Number: DR-72-06 Bosanka Village ;i"a-"a`.¶4 i�...Y,.!lHN-i':fiMit1.SS71r::�::q+rt,:akC :'`; µ 4: 1:• �.�u:." :F"' g= i ' Monumentshould act as a directory and not L sign �;; .. ...;<: .; ' i,r,%t 7', ,1 is an opportunity !,,,,=sliw. M .T -r ,., advertising the building. Therepp tY ''r y.i�.�pst,:�::'1 l�±�i:��"Pin G'Sy� tic , ,. height and consolidatetenant names with ▪;Zi.")V..47. - eA'Sn4i,:'a�lVtl to reduce :� .:. x ' , G; r� Tenants �,:::140.:r;�x ::115 ; K � adequate visual representation. • >M'�,- � ��:•��:�.�� more than eP ,;a:•x sa u.;a_,:xe.2, z ., 1. on the Building. Will '-5 . ,• "`,, _ have adequate representation k::;?;:' Zisy'it i.:•1r.;_ '(` ji's :' h:�,..k„"` additional 3' to overall size '''' *"1;! cT,i4 = y '` `°`t:.. y� the planter would add an T;i <.r _+� = ,=,Ai z ;107 a would have less visual clutter if - . f:"y . �:; :;��";: ol'sign. Sign o , f�,: f;>,; :,...4 > color. . :r�-;�,.z'. '`s`.`�~':'`: �:'°•�� tenant background an were all the same ,```>. " G;,-.i.,.; & :. .„,,,,;.e_, ;^:, rf"+•`..„,,,t;L:,',:,,:, #5C DR-76-06 Medical Professional Bldg `. . -%;�-,:,-:• �,��--'� 'w ..��:�'� 2. File Number: %v}; r'?� r:`' `` " 5=:�<; ' p he ting holes in mortar Joints so as =�. . aiWi = a.�kag�,l Kee t moon J .: : . .., ,••:1.^: :,.),,<„i4.,1* •;%alikehas been .-:v:41.,,t4.^ia '�rw;,1:'0 .r.. •�,. ;•••tx tenants change it does not look it f Jr;: .*Iii ; :: max; dynamic ;▪;� . •• ; -.,1,`,1-;:?:;'. >4..;.., . shot ed. Develop a more logo for :'v ` : > '=' "�•i'''":rr"i"'< .,.. '"1' developed yet(450 State Street) 't4-' `r� <`� ..,:� • �6.;4 t�ii wall if it hasn't been d p ���r>�'�;M�:�;rir.r��rt`^�:�, t;i>~:.„�4::.��r_h mC Tenant panels r.'r,.:•:.w•4y':::'," hf�•,;ati. ''-i .Aw'+`: �;��� ,,;;,•,._u;;,: ' i':�a`�,,,'�:�'; Wall seems somewhat oversized. • ::'.6.,iv o,..,41A z::,:;er- rthat would complement brick r ;k,t,MA...,,04 $, 4, could have a softer color p - ;,4`1,.,,T -"J': :.,-,,,,,, =-''u+ rather than stark white econolite. ..,„7.:z_ r•,,,,f ,:�:.,•. .: ..;.-: 06 Kathleen••~,�� �==-: �� :��-� � 3. File#78- 1Ca en Estates „•" _-7;-„: :.,• :;- ` e looks goad. c<,�, =` ;- , :; This on f'°g`' '`.ii,T.'"i•14.'``�-.,`l"" � Thanks Barb, see you next Tuesday. PHONE: (208)336•2769 FAX: (208)34,1•8285 email: clas5icOrn,cron.net 412 SOUTH SIXTH ST. BOISE,IDAHO 83702 rsi•. •=bus.,' Id Nd62:Z0 900Z 0I '6nd S8Z8VV280Z : 'ON XHd : 140e1d n't I.r.: . • •':: ::::•::'. • : .- ...•,•: :::': : i •i: : • ,-.: .:••••''.4;,.. • ::.. .7.4). g•o:'' . 1 , x . „,..4177a: ::'•- :. ..„ ...;'/.. .' .._#Z,....---'--- • .. . , ••••;.N1,:••c.:. .!,,,:,?0,1t,.,...,,;,.,,:t..., ,,,'.:;.:.:,.,..,.. ,,:. •'--'*, . tf: • • . • . • - ,\;::, s' i,:'ilil :''rf,m,,ra_ . -4i0.1.11/.'--;- • . • 4.148‘?; \ •,.‘z,‘, 0 it, „,,,,,4:,,pv ,,I,c. .,-7-,..,,.i,,..,,,,61,16.p/6,0,,fr.,,,,,....- .. ... . •. . . . . • • , .-,. •-:,..;-.4, ,I A 2, i lei ,,, -,, ::.,.., liv,•,44L.) . . • . ,:.1=1 Qr>. '.‘b •Siv... IIG-ri .. 4-. '''' ': 6TUDIC) .. • , . . . • '... __.. rd. 1____ _ „vki.,;,,,,, 0. . . • • . '''- . .- ::•-•:.::t.P ' qiitilid0.. .j.„.•;..:-''•• .. ' .. •, • , . ...4-e-7tn. :.•-• • • t Pckge 1 of 5 Date 7 • (0 (C)(::› : T../fAT/ r._ . . . i To: -FDrISSNR.4?"-- .---. ir5r.°11.1....NO..._et--.1—_HI__.--- .. .._______-_-1 • . ° filnone: 15.i - 0 z2 7 . 1 irpTine: . 21).13,34.4.74:41 ._ .7_71 __ 2.0.13.344.1•82135 • • • _. ..ji_Fox: _ _- ______.._ ...___— ____. 1 • i.-,E ZeGt. 5 "v- cm IQ Lc)t,3 (1,.)t-t-pk ik couPc6 . 24 0.626 ,,Sxre 0 s•IS , 6 W4.0 ti-IPs5 A- C-004,16Z" i, •1 1,e) Df-P. exa- ?os cci u .. v( s u A t.-- C,14A0,e_ E , . • I Dowt—rre)u-30 &IA6 L,.7,. •. iE , i • I C.„ )tit f) . t.u.C..4.1•-- f -..4•.>> ---S ell' 00 t,3&Y.-7- 1.1L3S7e(4.-- I• . ! 1 i • , ! i • • • 1 . • - • - . • 1 . • . - , , . - 1 1 . • 1 . I • . . . - i . . • 1 1 • i I• • . • •. •• • •• • • . . . • , . •CLASSIC DESIGN STUDIO 1 .. .•• ,i ,,, c c. . t• , : .1 I Q. /( ! /1 ''t I/ ..). ,)I X II ) ..)I 1 f-'(--•'i • -.1 ,!.• • -1(-). ‘",.\'Ti4itti 0()I'',("•,, . !(11,.3! !(..;' 0,) ., : .•• ; I •• . 1-• . .... . -.• - •---• • --. . . . . . . Ed WdOV:E0 900E 01 'Emlz1 S8E8VV280E : 'ON XUA : WONA • tagassamEr 4 —77-7 BOSAN KA VILLAGE • • • t • •,1 ,• /p / ,.• / t,// ,/ • . • )1 • • • 2d WdOV:ZO 900Z OT .6n13 S8Z81717280Z : 'ON Xlzid : 1,402:1A pp �p e ', - �I C y < 5 a x r,0 T `.l. yt4 + Du' �•y1 '7•+5• : 3 ham. .( c l- i t I y I .I a,• •.•�� • E "cc\ \. \\\\-3InRr:.,. I. w( s 4%r,._.,•:ll:,: v r ........_(.:,ri:,....;-/.,; ....7.,.i:::.:...;'..:i,ii1... i..1......,.:....li:;. 7.7',,,:6,n-'1,,.,i.-:-.,.1ft'4:.,•t".:,.,,,ni,.:"-..1.4,5*,"j.,4 .mow �} '1 se-( ✓ i-. 5 . P' ._, -..a 1 •.L.�r •r f�.- (1 . . _ 1 1►r ,tlw,ri•t.c • .'!�.i. T,.:{, • j i R '�' J .y r. .. r Z.- 0 ' .. . •." •''',..:t•i'',42....I'• •••- • CLOT CIn G .Fl` 0 4CWIll . 7 } LC v t�XI H D I Z I : NO�d td NdTV:ZO 900Z 0T '6nd S8z8bbz80z : '0N Xdd