Minutes - 2010 - City Council - 05/24/2010 - Special
EAGLE CITY COUNCIL
Special Meeting Minutes
May 24,2010
PRE-COUNCIL AGENDA: 5:30 V.m. - 6:30 V.m.
Acting Mayor Huffaker: I have been informed that Council Members Semanko and Grasser are
going to be late so we will go ahead and begin the Pre-Council Agenda.
1. Lower Boise River Interim Feasibility Revort: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Ellen
Berggren, presents a power point presentation and discusses the same. General discussion.
2. Treasure Vallev Comvrehensive Aauifer Manal!ement Plan (CAMP) vrocess: Idaho
Department of Water Resources. Helen Harrington distributes handouts, presents a power point
presentation and discusses the Treasure Valley Comprehensive Aquifer Management Plan.
General discussion.
REGULAR COUNCIL AGENDA: 6:30 p.m.
1. CALL TO ORDER: Acting Mayor Huffaker calls the meeting to order at 6:30 p.m.
2. ROLL CALL: HUFFAKER, SHOUSHTARIAN, SEMANKO, GRASSER. All present. A
quorum is present.
3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: Denise VanDoren leads the Pledge of Allegiance.
4. PUBLIC COMMENT: Patricia Mickiewicz discusses the intersection of Ballantyne and
Hwy 44. General discussion on the realignment of Ballantyne. Discussion on the upcoming
projects in Eagle with ACHD.
Debra Hilton, 1203 Selamar Court, I was unable to attend the meetings regarding the recycling
bins. They have now been delivered. I'm wondering how many of you have driven around the
neighborhoods and noticed the number oftrash bins and recycle bins that are sitting out in the
open. I am a strong supporter of recycling. General discussion.
Robert Hilton, discusses the size of the trash bins and the recycle bins. General discussion.
Semanko states that we should contact Allied Waste for additional options for recycling
containers.
5. CONSENT AGENDA:
. Consent Agenda items are considered to be routine and are acted on with one
motion. There will be no separate discussion on these items unless the Mayor, a
Councilmember, member of City Staff, or a citizen requests an item to be removed
from the Consent Agenda for discussion. Items removed from the Consent Agenda
will be placed on the Regular Agenda in a sequence determined by the City Council.
. Any item on the Consent Agenda which contains written Conditions of Approval
from the City of Eagle City Staff, Planning & Zoning Commission, or Design
Review Board shall be adopted as part of the City Council's Consent Agenda
approval motion unless specifically stated otherwise.
A. Claims Al!ainst the City.
B. Minutes of May 11.2010:
Page I
K:\CQUNCIL\MINUTES\Temporary Minutes Work Area\CC-OS-24-10min.doc
C. Avvointment to the Develovment Imvact Fee Advisorv Committee
(DIFAC): Council President/Acting Mayor Huffaker is requesting Council
confirmation of the Parks and Pathways Development Commission members to
also serve as on the Development Impact Fee Advisory Committee. Randy
Zollinger, Mike Barton, Mary McColl will be serving a four year term. Charles
Ferguson, Michael Hummel Don Stockton and Richard Talbert will be serving a
two year term. (MH)
D. Oven Container Permit: daVinci's is requesting an open container permit to be
used on June 12, 2010 from 11 :00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. on north 1 st Street between
State Street and the alley. Site plan approval has been obtained from City of
Eagle Police. Appropriate approval has also been obtained for the street closure
from Ada County Highway District.
E. Open Container Permit: Eagle Volunteer Firefighter's Association is requesting
an open container permit to be used on June 12,2010 from 5:00 p.m. to 10:00
p.m. at Merrill Park (637 E. Shore Dr.). Site plan approval has been obtained
from City of Eagle Police.
F. Noise Waiver Request: Eagle Volunteer Firefighter's Association is requesting a
noise waiver for June 12,2010 extending the time to midnight to allow for clean
up.
Council Member Shoushtarian removes Item #5A, Claims Against the City.
Shoushtarian moves to approve the Amended Consent Agenda, Items #B, C, D, E, and F.
Seconded by Grasser. ALL AYES: MOTION CARRIES.............
SA. Claims Al!ainst the City
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
Council Member Shoushtarian: my question is in regards to the $8,000.00 to be paid on the
buyout. General discussion.
Shoushtarian moves to approve the Claims Against the City. Seconded by Grasser.
Huffaker: AYE; Shoushtarian: AYE; Semanko: AYE: Grasser: AYE: ALL AYES:
MOTION CARRIES..............
6. PROCLAMATIONS & RESOLUTIONS:
A. Resolutionl0-18: A Resolution Of The City Council Of The City Of Eagle, Ada County,
Idaho, Adopting The Cobra Amendment; Authorizing The Mayor To Sign The Amendment; And
Providing For An Effective Date. (SKB)
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
Semanko moves to approve Resolutionl0-18: A Resolution of The City Council of Eagle,
Ada County, Idaho, Adopting The Cobra Amendment; Authorizing The Mayor To Sign
The Amendment; And Providing For An Effective Date. Seconded by Grasser. Huffaker:
AYE; Shoushtarian: AYE; Semanko: AYE: Grasser: AYE: ALL AYES: MOTION
CARRIES........... ...
B. Resolution 10-19: A Resolution Of The City Council Of The City Of Eagle, Ada County,
Idaho, Adopting The Cobra Amendment; Authorizing The Mayor To Sign The Amendment; And
Providing For An Effective Date. (SKB)
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
Page 2
K:\COUNCILIMINUTES\Temporary Minutes Work Area\CC-OS-24-lOmin.doc
Semanko moves to approve Resolution 10-19, a Resolution of The City Council of Eagle,
Ada County, Idaho, Adopting The Cobra Amendment; Authorizing The Mayor To Sign
The Amendment; And Providing For An Effective Date. Seconded by Grasser. Huffaker:
AYE; Shoushtarian: AYE; Semanko: AYE: Grasser: AYE: ALL AYES: MOTION
CARRIES........... ...
7. UNFINISHED BUSINESS:
A. Discussion of Mayoral avvointment:
AI. Discussion of City Council avvointment:
A.2 Oath of Office: If the Council has proceeded to appoint a mayor and/or city council
member, the City Clerk will administer the oath of office to the appointed Mayor
and/or Council person. Presentation of Certificates. (SKB)
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
General Council discussion.
Grasser moves to nominate Al Shoushtarian for the position of Mayor of Eagle. Seconded by
Shoushtarian. Huffaker: Nay: Shoushtarian: Aye: Semanko: Pass: Grasser: Aye; Semanko Nay:
MOTION FAILS.
Grasser moves to nominate Saundra McDavid for the position of Mayor of Eagle. Seconded by
Shoushtarian. Huffaker: Nay: Shoushtarian: Aye: Semanko: Nay: Grasser: Aye: MOTION
FAILS.
General discussion.
Grasser moves to nominate James Reynolds for the position of Mayor of Eagle. MOTION
FAILS. FOR A LACK OF A SECOND.
General discussion.
Discussion on the legality of the Council President acting as Mayor by reason of resignation.
General discussion.
Council Member Semanko will prepare a motion or a resolution for the June 8th Agenda to have
an Advisory Vote for Mayor.
B. Discussion rel!ardinl! Eal!le City Hall business hours: Public comment will be taken on
this item. Speakers are asked to limit their comments to 3 minutes.
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
Brad Cousin, do the costs out weigh the benefits. General discussion.
Mark Butler, I testified previously that you don't split up a shift. Discussion on splitting the
shift. I hope you go back to the 8:00 to 5:00. General discussion.
Patricia Mickiewicz, I'm confused why the phone wasn't answered. Will the Mayor's Assistant
be under this shift? General discussion.
General Council discussion.
Shoushtarian moves to change the City Hall hours to what it was before, 8-5 Monday to
Friday with normal full staff. Seconded by Grasser. General discussion. Shoushtarian
amends the motion to have this effective July 1,2010. Second concurs. Further discussion.
THREE AYES: HUFFAKER: NAY: MOTION CARRIES.....................
Page 3
K\COUNCIL\MlNUTES\Temporary Minutes Work Area\CC-OS-24-lOmin.doc
C. EXT-02-10/PP-22-06 - Preliminarv Plat Extension of Time for Symvhony Square
Subdivision - Tom Kalanl!e: Tom Kalange represented by Kerrigan Kalange, is requesting a
one (1) year extension of time for the preliminary plat approval for Symphony Square
Subdivision, a residential subdivision consisting of 19-1ots (14-residential and 5-common). The
6.20-acre site is located at the eastern terminus of West Flint Road approximately 2,1 OO-feet east
of Park Lane at 3391 West Flint Drive. (WEV) This item was continuedfrom the April 27, 2010
meeting.
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
Mark Bulter and Kerrigan Lalange: Butler: Kerrigan's family owns this property. Tom called
me and 1 told him that I didn't do this for a living anymore. I can answer any questions you have
about this, I am not working for these people, I told them that I would help them without any
charge. Butler discusses the transportation element of the project. General discussion.
Huffaker moves to approve EXT -02-10/PP-22-06 - Preliminary Plat Extension of Time for
Symphony Square Subdivision for a one year extension of time. Seconded by Semanko.
General discussion. THREE AYES: GRASSER NAY: MOTION CARRIES....................
D. Request for Provosal for the City Hall Facility:
Acting Mayor Huffaker: Council Member Semanko has requested that we move this item
to 9C. Seconded by Grasser. ALL AYES: MOTION CARRIES................
8. PUBLIC HEARINGS: None
9. NEW BUSINESS:
A. Discussion Eal!le Scout Proiect vrovosed by Brock Jones:
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
Brock Jones, displays overheads and provides Council an overview of his Eagle Scout Project.
General discussion.
Semanko moves to approve Brock's project contingent upon funding being secured from
outside sources and that the City Clerk be instructed to forward to us our invitation to
Brock's ceremony when it is received for the Eagle Scout ceremony. Seconded by Grasser.
ALL AYES: MOTION CARRIES.................
B. Discussion rel!ardinl! Eal!le Public Librarv business hours: Public comment will be taken
on this item. Speakers are asked to limit their comments to 3 minutes.
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
Debra Hilton, 1203 Selamar, you have to consider what you did earlier this evening, having set
standard hours. We need to think about the children in our community that use the Library. My
concern is that further hours could be cut because of the finances of the City.
Semanko explains what the Councils authority is over the Library.
Brad Cousins, 66 S. Furwood Avenue, I'm a volunteer off and on at the Library. Discusses
people not being able to make to the Library during there hours. Discusses the Community
Room not being open to the public which would be a source of revenue. Discussion on the great
opportunity to have a free Library.
Acting Huffaker reads Kay Johnson's remarks into the record.
Page 4
K\COUNCILIMINUTES\Temporary Minutes Work Area\CC-03-24-lOmin.doc
Mary Arner, 13401 W. Anabrook Drive, I don't live in Eagle but I do all of my shopping in Eagle
and I love this Library. They have the most helpful staff and they have a great selection. I would
love to have the Library go back to Saturday morning hours. With the Farmer's Market going on
it seems more logical to be open in the morning instead of the afternoon. I understand the budget
constraints.
Mark Butler, 1640 W. Washam Road, I don't go to the Library but my son goes all of the time. It
is such a good service offered by the City. The Library should be number two on your
preference list. I know that they can set their budget but maybe you can make a strong
recommendation when you pass the budget.
General discussion.
Shash Timmons, 336 Old Park Place, I have been a patron of the Library since it was moved
from the former location. I believe the Library needs to be open longer hours, a lot of people
work until 6:00. This is a very important part of our community. I don't have a computer at
home so I can use the Library. I would like to see the Library provide computer classes.
Russell Van Liew, 97 E. Fish Drive, I would like to second what has been said here. The Library
is one of the most important assets to this community.
Robert Hilton, 1203 Selamar, everybody has voiced their opinion on this and I agree to
everything that is said. The Library should be open the same hours as City Hall.
Ron Baker, Library Director, discusses the results of the survey and the Library hours. General
discussion.
Mary Berent, President of the Library Board: Provides Council some history on the hours of the
Library and restoring the Library hours. General discussion.
Ron Baker, a 9 hour restoration on Thursday for three months to start the first of July we would
need $8, 431.00 for staff costs. That would be for 9 hours on Thursdays. We did a couple of
other estimates, if we were to run only 5 hours on Thursday from 1-6 and do an additional 3
hours on Saturday making the hours 10:00 - 1 :00 and for 4 months this was almost $10,000.00.
The lowest cost would be the three month restoration. General discussion.
This issue will be a separate Agenda item on the June 1,2010 Special Meeting which will
include Budget discussion.
Debra Hilton, one thing that wasn't brought up but because ofthe budget cuts many ofthe
periodicals were not going to be purchased and the citizens of the community stepped up and
provided some funding.
Dave Berent: I agree that hours are important but content is equally important. Most of the
books that I get come from other Libraries around the valley. Discusses the survey conducted by
the Library. Discussion on the operational hours.
Ron Baker: we do have an active reserve for the Library in the amount of $160,000.00 which has
been in place for several years. We had a carry forward of $70,000.00 which we put in reserve
but we needed to use those funds. The Library has an adequate reserve fund.
C(7D). Reauest for Provosal for the City Hall Facilitv:
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
General discussion on changes to the Draft RFP.
Page 5
K:\COUNCIL\MINUTES\Temporary Minules Work Area\CC.OS.24-10min.doc
Huffaker moves to have the City Attorney prepare the RFP and send this out to us by
tomorrow and get this out by the end of the week. Seconded by Semanko. ALL AYES:
MOTION CARRIES...............
D(C). Permanent Slove Easement and Purchase Al!reement between the City of Eal!le and
Ada County Hil!hway District: Sidewalk improvement - 2nd Street to Academy Way. (WEV)
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
General discussion.
City Attorney Buxton: ACHD has agreed that they do not need the Purchase Agreement, the
Easement provides what they need to do the improvements. Just grant the Easement.
Semanko moves to approve the Permanent Slope Easement and authorize the Mayor and
City Clerk to sign the Agreement.
Seconded by Huffaker. Huffaker: AYE; Shoushtarian: AYE; Semanko: AYE: Grasser:
AYE: ALL AYES: MOTION CARRIES..............
D. Avvroval of expenditure to replace the wireless microvhones in Council Chamber:
(ME)
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
General discussion.
Council concurs not to approve this expenditure this fiscal year and discuss this expenditure in
the budget process for next fiscal year.
E. Discussion with the Planninl! and Zoninl! Commission rel!ardinl! their final decision
makinl! authority for land use applications.
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
General discussion on continuing this item.
Huffaker: This item will be moved to the Pre-Council Agenda on June 22, 2010.
So moved by Semanko. Seconded by Grasser. ALL AYES: MOTION CARRIES.............
10. REPORTS:
a. Mayor and Council Reports and Concerns:
Huffaker: the VIBE was postponed to the first Saturday in June.
I think that we need to recognize other outstanding events in our community. We have had the
most outstanding year in athletics in Eagle. It would be nice to set up a day to do a recognition
for these kids. Discussion on doing a Proclamation.
b. City Clerk/Treasurer Report: No report
c. Zoning Administrator's Report: No report
d. Public Works Director Report: No report
e. City Attorney Report: No report
11. EXECUTIVE SESSION:
A. Pendinl! and Threatened Litil!ation: I.C. 67-2345 (t)
Page 6
K\COUNCILIMINUTES\Temporary Minutes Work Area\CC-05-24-IOmin.doc
Acting Mayor Huffaker introduces the issue.
Semanko moves to amend the Agenda by adding personnel, I.C. 67-2345(a) and remove
pending and threatened litigation from Executive Session. Seconded by Grasser. ALL
AYE: MOTION CARRIES...................
Huffaker moves to go into Executive Session in accordance with I.C. 67-2345(a) personnel.
Seconded by Semanko. Huffaker: AYE; Shoushtarian: AYE; Semanko: AYE: Grasser:
AYE: ALL AYES: MOTION CARRIES..............
Council goes into Executive Session at 10:35 p.m.
Council discusses personnel issues.
Council leaves Executive Session at 11 :40 p.m.
12. ADJOURNMENT:
Semanko moves to adjourn. Seconded by Shoushtarian. ALL AYES: MOTION
CARRIES.................... ...
Hearing no further business, the Council meeting adjourned at 11:40 p.m.
Respectful1y submitted:
.bQ.~8 ~~
SHARON K. BERGMANN
CITY CLERK/TREASURER
MICHAEL HUFF
MAYOR
",,'ll II II ."'1I
....'" G f.,AGLJi......
..' 0' ....... ...
:- ~ ..- ... "'.
~ ....... 0 v.. A r Ii' .. .. -_
~ ....... .. ~'9. .. ~
: u: 0 _~:
- · " .' ,....- -
- -'-", ""\-0..0.
: ~ G ~v_-: -,.. :
.. .. · c.. v .,;-.......
~ -.. / -;J t-,(",... ~ ~
-:., ..-YCORPO".. ..:~ ...~
'., s ........ ~ '" ..'
", l' A Tt:: 0 ..,"
"1 rt P ",
1111.......'"
APPROVED:
A TRANSCRIBABLE RECORD OF THIS MEETING IS AVAILABLE AT EAGLE
CITY HALL
Page 7
K\COUNCILIMINUTES\Temporary Minutes Work Area\CC-Ol-24-1 Omin.doc
WHY ARE WE DEVELOPING A CAMP?
Al the dilectiuir. i t'he k1 Itu Legislaturre, the IWIZI; is develop
ink; a Cornpreherisive Aquifer Management Plan (CAMP) for the
h eature Valley Aquifer which will become a conii'or ref ii r rf 111f •
Idaho Shit(' Willer Plan.
The CAMP Pi cr.grarn is designed to develop aquifer management
plan; for managing ground and surface water resources into the
future. !lie plans will guide technical and martagemerit actions
undertaken by the Idaho Water Resource Board (IWRB) and the
Idaho Department of Water Resources. Once adopted, all state
agencies shall exercise their duties in a manner consistent with
the CAMP. The plan will also be submitted to the Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission and other federal agencies.
The specific goals of a CAMP are to:
» Provide reliable sources of water, projecting 50 years into
the future.
• Avoid conflict (i.e., the experience in the Eastern Snake
Plain Aquifer)
» Prioritize future state investments in water
» Bridge the gaps between future water needs and supply
WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR WHAT?
The CAMP program is under the authority of the Idaho Water Resource Board (IWRB). The IWRB is
r2sDo:,sible for appointing the Advisory Committee members and adopting a CAMP for the basins.
WHATA
COMPREHENSIVE
AQUIFER MANAGEMENT
PLAN IS NOT
» A CAMP is NOT a change to
or part of adjudication
» A CAMP is NOT associated
with Total Maximum Daily
Loads (TMDLs)
» A CAMP is NOT a change in
prior appropriations system
» A CAMP is NOT regulatory
Treasure Valley
Comprehensive Aquifer
Management Program (CAMP)
."T :_e the CAMP is adopted by the IWRB, it is submitted to the Idaho Legislature for final adoption.
St support for the IWRB is provided by the Planning Bureau of the Idaho Department of Watei
Resources. Staff provides administrative and technical assistance for IWRB programs and activities.
The advisory Committee provides recommendations to the IWRB for consideration in the final CAMP.
Citizens provide input and advice to the Advisory Committee and the Board. Technical consultants
provide data that will inform the discussions within the Advisory Committee and the IWRB.
Facilitators promote communication, understanding and agreement.
FOR MORE INFORMATION:
Helen Harrington -• Manager
Water Planning Section
Idaho Department of Water Resources
The Idaho Water Center
322 East Front Street
PO Box 83720
Boise, ID 83720-0098
Phone: (208) 287-4800
Fax: (208) 287-6700
Please visit our website:
www.idwr.idaho.gov/waterboard/WaterPlanning/CAMP/TV_CAMP.htm
This website contains background information, updates on the status
of the programs, and ways to submit comments.
IN 2009 the Idaho Water Resource Board began developing a long term water management
plan for the Treasure Valley. The final plan is anticipated to be complete in 2012.
The process is intended to investigate strategies and develop plans, which will lead to
sustainable water supplies and optimum use of the water resources.
Anticipated CAMP technical studies include:
• Cloud seeding options
» Possible southwest Idaho storage
opportunities (with the Corps of
Engineers)
• Addressing hydrologic data collection
needs
» Finding a balance between water use
and water supply
Anticipated Planning Work includes:
KEY ISSUES
» Population growth
>> Land conversions from agriculture to
urban uses
Significant ground water declines
have occurred in Southeast Boise and
south of Lake Lowell.
Moderate ground water declines have
occurred between Eagle, West Boise,
and Kuna.
Flooding
»
THE TECHNICAL COMPONENT
The technical and planning components wilt
not start from scratch. The Treasure Valley
Hydrologic Project released in 2004 provided
technical information needed to address issues
of water supply in the Treasure Valley.
The project included the development of a
water budget for the aquifer system and an
improved understanding of the hydrologic
system in the Treasure Valley.
Other studies that enhance understanding of
water in the Treasure Valley include:
» Domestic, Commercial, Municipal and
Industrial Water Demand Assessment and
Forecast in Ada and Canyon Counties
» Localized hydrogeologic studies in North
Ada County and East Ada/West Elmore
Counties
• Future Water Demand Study
» Evaluation of the impacts of climate
change on water supply
» Planning assessment of proposed
alternatives to meet future water
demands
Eagle
Caldwell •
•
Meridian .*
�'., Nampa Boise
•
Kuna
Miles.
12 18
LOWER BOISE RIVER
INTERIM FEASIBILITY STUDY
Ellen Berggren
Project Manager
Walla Walla District
Boise Outreach Office
May 24, 2010
Eagle City Council
US Army Corps of Engineers
BUILDING STRONG.
Coordinated Planning Efforts
Lower Boise
Interim Feasibility
Study
Treasure Valley
prehensive Aquifer
anagement Plan
Water Storage Assessment
BUILDING STRONG
5-2(1-70
1
Study Authority
• Water Resources Development Act
(WRDA) 1999, Section 414
I.. Flood control
• WRDA 2007, Section 4038
Ecosystem restoration & water supply
Study Area
Lower Boise River Basin =
Lucky Peak Dam to Snake River confluence
Boise River Basin
:. .•
...r,. CaWtclt iadc.r�n,
Ow FM • kBOISC
Sermon
.. ,,an
ANtrys.'
Rvrcfi:
BUILDING STRONG.:
BUILDING STRONG®
2
Interim Feasibility Scope
• Existing conditions
® Flood damage and economic analysis
■ Water storage analysis
• Plan next study phase
Study Phases
• Reconnaissance Study
► 1995 and 2001
• Feasibility Study
► Interim Feasibility Phase
• June 2009 — April 2012
► Feasibility Phase
• TBD
BUILDING STRONG
�.., B. Ro..r
an0 Tributaries. IJatw
BUILDING STRONGs
3
Existing Conditions
Plan Formulation
■ Identify problems and opportunities
■ Identify planning objectives and
constraints
■ Describe existing conditions/ future
without project conditions
BUILDING STRONG®
Existing Conditions
Planning Objectives
• Reduce risk to public safety from flooding.
• Reduce flood damages.
• Provide additional water supply.
• Improve riparian and floodplain habitat quantity/quality.
• Improve water quality.
• Improve recreational opportunities and safety.
BUILDING STRONG®
4
N
Existing Conditions
Boise River Regulation
f1EYACD0 BR:CC( Ck:11C 5'1,:71
rum ria
1.110 V.r
. a.YG [.I.s.
(�— CALOYEL▪ Lq BO:SE
DRAINAGE AREA = 2.680 M:LES
ADEPS', RAYC1 DAY
[Wattle 14 tO•S
Existing Conditions
Current Flood Risk
(as measured at Glenwood Bridge)
• Corps/Reclamation regulation
objective = 6,500 cfs
• Flood stage = 7,000 cfs
• Localized flooding begins = 4,500 cfs
• 3 -percent flood (35 -year event)
regulated to 7,200 cfs
• 1 -percent flood (100 -year event)
regulated to 16,600 cfs
BUILDING STRONG®
1943 — Flood in Eagle, ID
2008 - Eagle, Idaho
BUILDING STRONG®
5
What is the Risk of Flooding?
Years in
Floodplain
1
2
3
4
5
10
15
20
25
30
at least one
10 -yr flood
least one
50 -yr flood
10% 2%
19% 4%
27% 6%
34% 8%
at least one
100 -yr flood
1%
2%
3%
4%
41% 10% 5%
65% 18% 10%
79% 26% 14% 3%
88% 33% 18% 4%
93% 40% 22% 5%
96% 45% 26% 6%
at least one
500 -yr flood
BUILDING STRONG,
RISK =
Potential for Flood x Consequence of Flood
Consequence of Flood
Unlikely to Occur
High Consequence
MODERATE RISK
Likely to Occur
High Consequence
Unlikely to Occur
Low Consequence
LOW RISK
Likely to Occur
Low Consequence
Potential for Flood
BUILDING STRONG,
6
Flood Damage & Economic Analysis
• Update hydraulic models & floodplain map
• Update existing flood damage curves
• Estimate flood damages prevented
Water Storage Analysis
• Middle Fk Boise drainage
- Alexander Flats
- Twin Springs;�r►'xy
• ,;,'"rc
North Fk Boise drainage •, ��`y_;,
- Rabbit Creek
- Barber Flats
• South Fk Boise drainage"'r-
- Anderson Ranch Dam
- Krall Mountain
• Main Boise drainage
- Arrowrock
- Lucky Peak
- Grimes Creek
- Dunnigan Creek (Mores Ck)
- Indian Creek -Mayfield
- Firebird (Willow Ck)
en,
BUILDING STRONGe
BUILDING STRONG,
7
Water Storage Analysis
■ Middle Fk Boise drainage
- Alexander Flats
- Twin Springs
• North Fk Boise drainage
- Barber Flats
• Main Boise drainage
- Arrowrock
- Lucky Peak
- Dunnigan Creek (Mores Ck)
BUILDING STRONG,,,
Water Storage Analysis
Second -level Screening Criteria
How do the sites compare with respect to .. .
• Meeting future water demand?
• Reducing flood risk?
• Hydropower potential?
• Technical feasibility?
• Relative cost?
• Avoiding social effects?
• Avoiding environmental effects?
• Avoiding resource management conflicts?
• Avoiding legal conflicts?
••••••i ••i ••
•
• •
BUILDING STRONG,
8
Plan Next Study Phase
• Interim Feasibility Report
► Existing conditions description
► Water storage assessment results
► Floodplain inventory
► Scope of work to complete
feasibility study
• Identify partners/sponsors
BUILDING STRONG,)
Time Line
• Water Storage Assessment
► Screening Analysis
• Public Meetings w/draft screening results:
> June 28 — Caldwell ID
• June 29 — Boise, ID
• June 29— Eagle, ID
> July 1 — Idaho City. ID
• Screening Analysis Finalized: August 31, 2010
► Engineering Design/Cost Estimates — July 2011*
• Floodplain Mapping - April 2011*
• Economic Analysis / Flood Damages - May 2011*
• Draft Interim Feasibility Report - December 2011*
• Final Interim Feasibility Report - April 2012*
Contingent on Congressional appropriations.
BUILDING STRONG
9
For More Information
Ellen Berggren, Project Manager
US Army Corps of Engineers, Walla Walla District
Ellen.M.Berggren@usace.army.mil
208.345.2065
Webpage: www.nww.usace.army.mil/boise/brifs/default.asp
Cynthia Bridge Clark, Project Manager
Idaho Department of Water Resources
cynthia.clark@idwr.idaho.gov
208.287.4817
www.idwr idaho.gov/waterboard/WaterPlanning/CAMP/TV_CAMP.htm
BUILDING STRONGe
10
Comprehensive Aquifer Management and Planning Program
In the Treasure Valley
Presentation to the Eagle City Council
May 24, 2010
Helen Harrington
Idaho Department of Water Resources
The CAMP Program
2008 Legislation
House Bills No. 428 and 644
Created Aquifer Planning and
Management Program under the authority
of the Idaho Water Resource Board
New Idaho Code Sections: 42-1779
42-1780
1
IDAHO
Water Resource Board
Purpose
Establish framework and path forward which will
lead to sustainable water supplies and optimum use
of water
Conduct statewide comprehensive aquifer planning
and management effort over a 10 -year period
Avoid the Eastern Snake Plain type conflicts in other
areas of the state
Develop management plans for selected basins with
potential ground -surface water conflicts or other
identified needs
Prellmma.y Apiiitey Study 9oumla.iee
CIO ▪ � �vro.
ME %Wan
IUah.
• Falls
�Ha ley•
ESPA
Twin
Falls Pocatello
1
2
Program Design
Hydrologic Component
J Planning Component
Stakeholder Component
1 Coordination/Leverage with other
activities and projects
TREASURE VALLEY CAMP
Current Activities
Initial Scoping of Issues and Concerns
Collaborative Processes (facilitation team) conducted
interviews in September/October
Situation Assessment/Advisory Committee Recommendations
Released on January 13, 2010
Advisory Committee
Established in March, two meetings held (April, May)
Ongoing Hydrologic and Planning Studies
3
Hydrologic Studies
J Northern and Eastern Ada County Ground Water
Studies
J Evaluate existing ground water models
- Establish Monitoring Network
- Develop Hydrologic Framework
1 Prepare/Update Water Balance
- Create/Refine Ground Water Model
Planning Studies
J Water Demand Projections (50 years)
1 Evaluate impacts of climate change on
future water supplies and strategies for
meeting future water demand
1 Storage Feasibility Study
Ground Water Recharge
4
Anticipated Planning Studies
Evaluate alternatives for meeting projected demands
or changing supply:
▪ Water Use Transfers J Inter -basin Transfers
▪ Weather Modification J Conservation
Feasibility
Additional alternatives from the Advisory Committee
Stakeholder and
Public Involvement
1 Stakeholder Advisory Committee
j Recommendations to IWRB
Public meetings
5
TREASURE VALLEY CAMP
Tentative Schedule
March 2010 Advisory Committee Established
September 2010 Technical and Planning Studies generally
complete
June 2011 Advisory Committee Recommended Aquifer
Management Plan to IWRB
August 2011 Draft Aquifer Management Plan circulated for
public comment and hearings
November 2011 Aquifer Management Plan Adopted by IWRB
For Additional Information:
http://www.idwr.idaho.qov/waterboard
/Planning/CAMP/CAMP.htm
Helen Harrington
Manager, Water Planning Section
Idaho Department of Water Resources
208-287-4848
Helen harnr ton:a_ idwr Idaho (Jo.
6